Gulia, Laura
17 results
The search returned 17 results
Now showing 1 - 10 of 17
- Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , An experiment on earthquake size distribution estimations reveals unexpected large epistemic uncertainty across methods
(-UK: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. -[Oxford]: Blackwell Science., 2025-05-28); ; ; ; The earthquake size distribution is well described by the Gutenberg Richter Law, controlled by the b-value parameter. In recent decades, a great variety of methods for estimating the b-value have been proposed by the scientific community, despite the simplicity of this relationship. All these methods underlie the different views of individual modellers and, therefore, often generate inconsistent results. In thisstudy, we perform a seismological experiment in which we compare different, commonly adopted, methodologies, to estimate the completeness magnitude and the b-value, for seismicity in Central Italy. The intermethod differences are on average equal to 0.4 and 0.3, for Mc and b, respectively, but reach much larger values, especially during more intense seismic activity. Thisshowsthat epistemic uncertainty in the b-value plays a more crucial role than intramethod uncertainties, opening new perspectives in the interpretation of discrepant, single studies.12 43 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , Earthquakes Parameters from Citizen Testimonies: A Retrospective Analysis of EMSC Database
We aim to compute macroseismic parameters (location and magnitude) using the BOXER code for the first time on the citizen testimonies, that is, individual intensity data points (IDPs) at the global scale collected and made available by the LastQuake system of the European–Mediterranean Seismological Centre (EMSC). IDPs available for different earthquakes are selected to eliminate those that are geographically inconsistent with most data; then they are clustered spatially based on various methods. For each cluster with at least three IDPs, a macroseismic data point (MDP), corresponding to an intensity value assessed for given localities as in classical macroseismic studies, is computed by various central tendency estimators (average, median, and trimmed averages). Finally, macroseismic parameters are obtained by MDP distribution using two location methods of BOXER code. For each earthquake, we used raw and corrected intensities and 132 different combinations of grouping methods, estimators, and BOXER methods. We assigned a ranking to the combinations that best reproduce instrumental parameters and used such a ranking to select preferred combinations for each earthquake. We analyzed retrospectively the reliability of the parameters as a function of time and space. The results are essentially identical using original and corrected intensities and show higher reliability for BOXER’s method 1 than for method 0; they are dependent on the geographical area, and generally improve over time and with the number of IDPs collected. These findings are useful for the future real-time analyses, and for evaluating the location and magnitude of earthquakes whenever a sufficient number of IDPs are available and with a distribution such that MDPs can be derived and the BOXER method applied.112 176 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , Improving the Foreshock Traffic Light Systems for Real-Time Discrimination Between Foreshocks and Aftershocks
(2024); ; ; ;Enescu, BogdanAfter a moderate-to-large earthquake, Civil Protection, scientists, the population, and decision makers immediately ask: "Was this the mainshock, or is a bigger event yet to come?" According to the current state of the art, the probability that an even larger event will occur within five days and 10 km after a moderate earthquake is typically 5%. Recent work proposes that a more specific answer to this question is possible (Gulia and Wiemer, 2019). The method allows real-time discrimination between foreshocks and aftershocks in well-monitored regions. However, so far, some expert judgments are required to adapt the technique to the case-specific data, such as defining the overall magnitude of completeness and the duration of the short-term aftershock incompleteness. Here, we introduce and retrospectively test an improved version of the foreshock traffic light system (FTLS) approach that successfully overcomes the aforementioned limits using the b-positive estimator (van der Elst, 2021). With these improvements, an FTLS assessment can be fully automated as early as one hour after an M ≥ 6 event without requiring expert judgments. We also test the updated approach on six additional sequences; the results align with the FTLS hypothesis.23 39 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Restricted , Comment on “High-Definition Mapping of the Gutenberg–Richter b-Value and Its Relevance: A Case Study in Italy” by M. Taroni, J. Zhuang, and W. Marzocchi
Taroni et al. (2021) published a statistical framework to reliably estimate the b-value and its uncertainties, with the goal being the interpretation in a seismotectonic context and improving earthquake forecasting capabilities. In this comment, we show that the results presented for the Italian region and the conclusions drawn by the authors, are heavily biased due to quarry-blast events in the Italian earthquake catalog used in the analysis. Without removing this anthropogenic component in the data, a meaningful analysis of the earthquake- size distribution for natural seismicity is, in our opinion, not possible. This comment highlights the need for basic data quality analysis before sophisticated statistical tools are applied to a dataset.55 216 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , Contamination of Frequency–Magnitude Slope (b-Value) by Quarry Blasts: An Example for Italy
Artifacts often affect seismic catalogs. Among them, the presence of man-made contaminations such as quarry blasts and explosions is a well-known problem. Using a contaminated dataset reduces the statistical significance of results and can lead to erroneous conclusions, thus the removal of such nonnatural events should be the first step for a data analyst. Blasts misclassified as natural earthquakes, indeed, may artificially alter the seismicity rates and then the b-value of the Gutenberg and Richter relationship, an essential ingredient of several forecasting models. At present, datasets collect useful information beyond the parameters to locate the earthquakes in space and time, allowing the users to discriminate between natural and nonnatural events. However, selecting them from webservices queries is neither easy nor clear, and part of such supplementary but fundamental information can be lost during downloading. As a consequence, most of statistical seismologists ignore the presence in seismic catalog of explosions and quarry blasts and assume that they were not located by seismic networks or in case they were eliminated. We here show the example of the Italian Seismological Instrumental and Parametric Database. What happens when artificial seismicity is mixed with natural one?35 169 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , Pseudoprospective Evaluation of the Foreshock Traffic-Light System in Ridgecrest and Implications for Aftershock Hazard Assessment
(2020-07-08); ; ; ; The Mw 7.1 Ridgecrest earthquake sequence in California in July 2019 offered an opportunity to evaluate in near‐real time the temporal and spatial variations in the average earthquake size distribution (the b‐value) and the performance of the newly introduced foreshock traffic‐light system. In normally decaying aftershock sequences, in the past studies, the b‐value of the aftershocks was found, on average, to be 10%–30% higher than the background b‐value. A drop of 10% or more in “aftershock” b‐values was postulated to indicate that the region is still highly stressed and that a subsequent larger event is likely. In this Ridgecrest case study, after analyzing the magnitude of completeness of the sequences, we find that the quality of the monitoring network is excellent, which allows us to determine reliable b‐values over a large range of magnitudes within hours of the two mainshocks. We then find that in the hours after the first Mw 6.4 Ridgecrest event, the b‐value drops by 23% on average, compared to the background value, triggering a red foreshock traffic light. Spatially mapping the changes in b-values, we identify an area to the north of the rupture plane as the most likely location of a subsequent event. After the second, magnitude 7.1 mainshock, which did occur in that location as anticipated, the b‐value increased by 26% over the background value, triggering a green traffic light. Finally, comparing the 2019 sequence with the Mw 5.8 sequence in 1995, in which no mainshock followed, we find a b‐value increase of 29% after the mainshock. Our results suggest that the real‐time monitoring of b‐values is feasible in California and may add important information for aftershock hazard assessment.150 193 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Restricted , Fast characterization of sources of recent Italian earthquakes from macroseismic intensities
We analysed the intensity data collected immediately after three strong earthquakes (Mw≥6) that occurred in Italy in the last decade to infer location, orientation and size of the relevant seismogenic faults using the Boxer method. We show that, starting from a few hours after the earthquake, such macroseismic method could have provided a characterization of the seismogenic source comparable to instrumental methods, some of which would have required much more time to provide stable results. Particularly for the 6 April 2009 earthquake, the analysis of macroseismic survey data could have been able to accurately constrain, starting already from the early afternoon of the day of the main shock, location, orientation and size of the area of maximum coseismic displacement, related to the activation of the Paganica-S. Demetrio fault system. For the 20 May 2012 Emilia and the 24 August 2016 Amatrice earthquakes, preliminary macroseismic surveys were carried out within a few days from the main shocks, but their data were made available publicly a month later. For the 20 May 2012 Emilia earthquake, the orientation of the fault could have been correctly determined even if the size would have been underestimated. For the 24 August 2016 Amatrice earthquake, both the orientation and the size could have been correctly assessed. We also compared such macroseismic determinations with those obtained for some historical earthquakes in the same areas. The analysis of the cumulate intensities observed after the shocks of 24 August, 26 and 30 October 2016 indicates an overall Mw 6.8 comparable to that (Mw 6.9) of the largest earthquake occurred in the same section of the Apennines (14 January 1703). Even if the inferred orientations of the 2016 and 1703 boxes are very similar, the epicentres differ of about 20 km indicating a probable distinct fault system for the two earthquakes.307 120 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , The Effect of a Mainshock on the Size Distribution of the Aftershocks
(2018-12); ; ; ; A systematic decay of the aftershock rate over time is one of the most fundamental empirical laws in Earth science. However, the equally fundamental effect of a mainshock on the size distribution of subsequent earthquakes has still not been quantified today and is therefore not used in earthquake hazard assessment. We apply a stacking approach to well-recorded earthquake sequences to extract this effect. Immediately after a mainshock, the mean size distribution of events, or b-value, increases by 20-30%, considerably decreasing the chance of subsequent larger events. This increase is strongest in the immediate vicinity of the mainshock, decreasing rapidly with distance but only gradually over time. We present a model that explains these observations as a consequence of the stress changes in the surrounding area caused by the mainshocks slip. Our results have substantial implications for how seismic risk during earthquake sequences is assessed.176 287 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , Detection of quarry and mine blast contamination in European regional catalogues
(2010-09); ;Gulia, Laura; Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia, Sezione Bologna, Bologna, ItaliaSeismic catalogues often include man-made contaminations, that range from the changes in seismic networks operating in the region to the different processing of the data and to the inclusion of quarry explosions and marine shots. For example, the installation or closure of seismic stations produce an increase or a decrease in the detection of small events, whilst quarry blasts or mine explosions artificially enrich catalogues. Despite network operators’ best efforts to identify quarry blasts, it is easy to find these events in a catalogue, whereas the separation between explosion events and tectonic ones is a difficult task. Detection and removing of artificial events from a seismic catalogue should be the preliminary step in any analysis of statistical seismology. Wiemer and Baer (BSSA, 2000) proposed an algorithm, based on a statistical criterion, to identify and remove quarry explosions from catalogues. It is based on the observation that quarry blasts generally take place during daytime hours: the areas with a high ratio of daytime and night-time events are likely to be regions with quarry activity. In the first part of this work (Gulia, NH, 2010) we have modified the method and then tested it, using both a synthetic and a regional catalogue; in the second part the procedure has been applied to some of the European regional catalogues available on line. The comparison between the results obtained and the location of known quarries and mines for the analyzed catalogues confirms both the presence of non-natural events in seismic catalogue and the reliability of the methodology in identifying mining areas.104 235 - Some of the metrics are blocked by yourconsent settings
Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access , Tectonic regimes and earthquake size distribution: new evidence f or PSHA
(2010-09); ; ;Gulia, Laura; Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia, Sezione Bologna, Bologna, Italia ;Wiemer, Stefan; Swiss Seismological Service, ETH ZurichEarthquake catalogues, seismotectonic zonations and ground-motion prediction equations (GMPE) are the basic ingredients for probabilistic seismic hazard assessment (PSHA). Seismotectonic zones are commonly defined considering the style-of-faulting; contemporary GMPE’s also differentiate by the style-of-faulting. Here we present a case study for Italy to show that style-of-faulting should also be incorporated into the recurrence rates estimation. In the past 40 years many studies relating b-values of the Gutenberg and Richter law to physical properties have been performed, from laboratory rock specimens to observations in different tectonic regimes. Various authors analyzed the correlation between b-value and tectonic regimes and the results are generally consistent: as power laws indicate scale invariance, the inverse dependence of the b-value on the differential stress is universally valid and the parameter can therefore be interpreted as a ‘stressmeter’ in the Earth’s crust. A consequence of the inverse dependency of the b-value on differential stress is that tectonics regimes with different dominant faulting styles should exhibit significantly different b-values, in particular the highest values for normal events (bNR), followed by strike-slip ( bSS) and reverse (bTH): bTH < bSS < bNR. In this study, we evaluate this hypothesis for the first time, using data from the Italian Peninsula, whose complex geology is reflected in a strongly variable stress field and distinctly different faulting regimes. Extensional, compressional and strike-slip regimes are simultaneously present. T he study region fulfils two other critical requirements: 1)the regional seismic monitoring of the microseismicity of the past two decades was good enough to allow detailed mapping of the b-value and 2) a rich catalogue of focal mechanism exists that allows a detailed seismotectonic zonation. Because the b–value is a critical parameter in PSHA, linking it firmly to regional faulting style has significant implications for future regional PSHA studies. At present the b-values are not used for zonation purposes, but they are either assigned regionally or computed for each zone, where zones are in general defined based on expert judgment. We suggest that future seismotectonic zonation models should take into account the knowledge on faulting style dependence of b-values. T here are a variety of way how this can be achieved, for example using high resolution mapping of b as an input for zonation, or by using the b-values of the large scale tectonic zones as a prior, deviating only if local b-values are found to be significantly different from the regional ones.136 286
