Evaluating the incompleteness magnitude using an unbiased estimate of the b value
Author(s)
Language
English
Status
Published
JCR Journal
JCR Journal
Peer review journal
Yes
Issue/vol(year)
/236(2024)
ISSN
0956-540X
Electronic ISSN
1365-246X
Publisher
Oxford University Press on behalf of The Royal Astronomical Society
Pages (printed)
994-1001
Date Issued
2024
Abstract
The evaluation of the b value of the Gutenberg–Richter (GR) law, for a sample composed of n
earthquakes, presents a systematic positive bias δb which is proportional to 1/n . In this study,
we show how to incorporate in δb the bias introduced by deviations from the GR law. More
precisely we show that δb is proportional to the square of the variability coefficient CV, defined
as the ratio between the standard deviation of the magnitude distribution and its mean value.
When the magnitude distribution follows the GR law CV = 1 and this allows us to introduce a
new graphical procedure, based on the dependence of b on n, which allows us to identify the
incompleteness magnitude mc as the threshold magnitude leading to CV = 1. The method is
tested on synthetic catalogues and it is applied to estimate mc in Southern California, Japan
and New Zealand.
earthquakes, presents a systematic positive bias δb which is proportional to 1/n . In this study,
we show how to incorporate in δb the bias introduced by deviations from the GR law. More
precisely we show that δb is proportional to the square of the variability coefficient CV, defined
as the ratio between the standard deviation of the magnitude distribution and its mean value.
When the magnitude distribution follows the GR law CV = 1 and this allows us to introduce a
new graphical procedure, based on the dependence of b on n, which allows us to identify the
incompleteness magnitude mc as the threshold magnitude leading to CV = 1. The method is
tested on synthetic catalogues and it is applied to estimate mc in Southern California, Japan
and New Zealand.
References
Aki, K., 1965. Maximum likelihood estimate of b in the formula log n =a
−bm and its confidence limits, Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst., Univ. Tokyo, 43,
237–239.
Amitrano, D., 2003. Brittle-ductile transition and associated seismicity: ex perimental and numerical studies and relationship with the b value, J.
geophys. Res., 108(B1), doi:10.1029/2001JB000680.
Amorese ` , D., 2007. Applying a change-point detection method on
frequency-magnitude distributions, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 97(5), 1742–
1749.
Bottiglieri, M., Lippiello, E., Godano, C. & de Arcangelis, L., 2009. Identi fication and spatiotemporal organization of aftershocks, J. geophys. Res.,
114(B3), doi:10.1029/2008JB005941.
Cao, A. & Gao, S.S., 2002. Temporal variation of seismic b-values beneath
northeastern Japan island arc, Geophys. Res. Lett., 29(9), 48–1-48-3.
de Arcangelis, L., Godano, C., Grasso, J.R. & Lippiello, E., 2016. Statistical
physics approach to earthquake occurrence and forecasting, Phys. Rep.,
628, 1–91 .
de Arcangelis, L., Godano, C. & Lippiello, E., 2018. The overlap of after shock coda-waves and short-term post seismic forecasting, J. geophys.
Res., 123(7), 5661–5674.
Garcia-Hernandez, R., D Auria, L., Barrancos, J., Padilla, G.D. & Perez,
N.M., 2021. Multiscale temporal and spatial estimation of the b-value,
Seismol. Res. Lett., 92(6), 3712–3724.
Godano, C., 2017. A new method for the estimation of the completeness
magnitude, Phys. Earth planet. Inter., 263, 7–11.
Godano, C. & Petrillo, G., 2022. Estimating the completeness mag nitude mc and the b-values in a snap, Earth Space Sci., 10(2),
doi:10.1029/2022EA002540.
Godano, C., Lippiello, E. & de Arcangelis, L., 2014. Variability of the
b value in the Gutenberg–Richter distribution, Geophys. J. Int., 199(3),
1765–1771.
Godano, C., Tramelli, A., Petrillo, G., Bellucci Sessa, E. & Lippiello, E.,
2022. The dependence on the Moho depth of the b-value of the Gutenberg Richter law, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 112(4), 1921–1934.
Gulia, L. & Wiemer, S., 2010. The influence of tectonic regimes on the
earthquake size distribution: a case study for Italy, Geophys. Res. Lett.,
37(10), doi:10.1029/2010GL043066.
Gulia, L. & Wiemer, S., 2019. Real-time discrimination of earthquake fore shocks and aftershocks., Nature, 574, 193–199.
Gutenberg, B. & Richter, C., 1944. Frequency of earthquakes in California,
, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 34, 185–188.
Hainzl, S., 2016a. Apparent triggering function of aftershocks resulting
from rate–dependent incompleteness of earthquake catalogues, J. geo phys. Res., 121(9), 6499–6509.
Hainzl, S., 2016b. Rate-dependent incompleteness of earthquake catalogues,
Seismol. Res. Lett., 87(2A), 337–344.
Hauksson, E., Yang, W. & Shearer, P.M., 2012. Waveform relocated earth quake catalogue for Southern California (1981 to June 2011), Bull. seism.
Soc. Am., 102(5), 2239–2244.
Helmstetter, A., Kagan, Y.Y. & Jackson, D.D., 2006. Comparison of short term and time-independent earthquake forecast models for Southern Cal ifornia, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 96(1), 90–106.
Herrmann, M. & Marzocchi, W., 2021. Inconsistencies and lurking pitfalls
in the magnitude frequency distribution of high-resolution earthquake
catalogues, Seismol. Res. Lett., 92(2A), 909–922.
Kagan, Y.Y., 2004. Short-term properties of earthquake catalogues and mod els of earthquake source, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 94(4), 1207–1228.
Lippiello, E., de Arcangelis, L. & Godano, C., 2008. Influence of time and
space correlations on earthquake magnitude, Phys. Rev. Lett., 100(3),
doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.038501.
Lippiello, E., Godano, C. & de Arcangelis, L., 2012. The earthquake mag nitude is influenced by previous seismicity, Geophys. Res. Lett., 39(5),
doi:10.1029/2012GL051083.
Lippiello, E., Petrillo, G., Landes, F. & Rosso, A., 2019. Fault heterogeneity
and the connection between aftershocks and afterslip, Bull. seism. Soc.
Am., 109(3), 1156–1163.
Lippiello, E., Petrillo, G., Landes, F. & Rosso, A., 2021. The genesis of
aftershocks in spring slider models, in Statistical Methods and Modeling
of Seismogenesis, Chapter 5, pp. 131–151, Wiley.
Marzocchi, W., Spassiani, I., Stallone, A. & Taroni, M., 2019a. How to be
fooled searching for significant variations of the b-value, Geophys. J. Int.,
220(3), 1845–1856.
Marzocchi, W., Spassiani, I., Stallone, A. & Taroni, M., 2019b. How to be
fooled searching for significant variations of the b-value, Geophys. J. Int.,
220(3), 1845–1856.
Mignan, A., 2012. Functional shape of the earthquake frequency-magnitude
distribution and completeness magnitude, J. geophys. Res., 117(B8),
doi:10.1029/2012JB009347.
Mogi, K., 1962. Study of the elastic shocks caused by the fracture of hetero geneous materials and itsrelation to earthquake phenomena, Bull. Earthq.
Res. Inst. Tokyo Univ., 40, 125–173.
Nanjo, K., 2020. Were changesin stressstate responsible for the 2019 Ridge crest, California, earthquakes?, Nat. Commun., 11, doi:10.1038/s41467-
020-16867-5.
Nanjo, K.Z., Hirata, N., Obara, K. & Kasahara, K., 2012. Decade-scale
decrease in b value prior to the M9-class 2011 Tohoku and 2004 Sumatra
quakes, Geophys. Res. Lett., 39(20), doi:10.1029/2012GL052997.
Nava, F.A., Marquez-Ram ´ ´ırez, V.H., Zuniga, ˜ F.R., Avila-Barrientos, ´ L. &
Quinteros, C.B., 2016. Gutenberg-Richter b-value maximum likelihood
estimation and sample size, J. Seismol., 21, 127–135.
Ogata, Y. & Katsura, K., 1993. Analysis of temporal and spatial hetero geneity of magnitude frequency distribution inferred from earthquake
catalogues, Geophys. J. Int., 113(3), 727–738.
Ogata, Y. & Yamashina, K., 1986. Unbiased estimate for b-value of magni tude frequency, J. Phys. Earth, 34(2), 187–194.
Omi, T., Ogata, Y., Hirata, Y. & Aihara, K., 2013. Forecasting large
aftershocks within one day after the main shock, Sci. Rep., 3,
doi:10.1038/srep02218.
Omi, T., Ogata, Y., Shiomi, K., Enescu, B., Sawazaki, K. & Aihara, K., 2016.
Automatic aftershock forecasting: a test using real-time seismicity data
in Japan, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 106(6), 2450–2458.
Peng, Z., Vidale, J.E., Ishii, M. & Helmstetter, A., 2007. Seismicity rate im mediately before and after main shock rupture from high-frequency wave forms in Japan, J. geophys. Res., 112(B3), doi:10.1029/2006JB004386.
Petrillo, G., Landes, F., Lippiello, E. & Rosso, A., 2020. The influence of
the brittle-ductile transition zone on aftershock and foreshock occurrence,
Nat. Commun., 11, 1–10.
Petruccelli, A., Schorlemmer, D., Tormann, T., Rinaldi, A., Wiemer, S.,
Gasperini, P. & Vannucci, G., 2019. The influence of faulting style on
the size-distribution of global earthquakes, Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 527,
doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2019.115791.
Rydelek, P.A. & Sacks, I.S., 2001. Migration of large earthquakes along the
San Jacinto Fault; stress diffusion from the 1857 Fort Tejon earthquake,
Geophys. Res. Lett., 28(16), 3079–3082.
Scholz, C., 1968. The frequency-magnitude relation of microfracturing in
rock and its relation to earthquakes, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 58, 399–415.
Scholz, C.H., 2015. On the stress dependence of the earthquake b value,
Geophys. Res. Lett., 42(5), 1399–1402.
Schorlemmer, D. & Woessner, J., 2008. Probability of detecting an earth quake, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 98(5), 2103–2117.
Shi, Y. & Bolt, B.A., 1982. The standard error of the magnitude-frequency
b value, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 72(5), 1677–1687.
Tormann, T., Wiemer, S. & Mignan, A., 2014. Systematic survey of high resolution b value imaging along Californian faults: inference on asperi ties, J. geophys. Res., 119(3), 2029–2054.
Tormann, T., Enescu, B., Woessner, J. & Wiemer, S., 2015. Randomness of
megathrust earthquakes implied by rapid stress recovery after the Japan
earthquake, Nat. Geosci., 8, 152–158.
Tramelli, A., Godano, C., Ricciolino, P., Giudicepietro, F., Caliro, S.,
Orazi, M., De Martino, P. & Chiodini, G., 2021. Statistics of seismic ity to investigate the Campi Flegrei caldera unrest, Sci. Rep., 11(1),
doi:10.1038/s41598-021-86506-6.
Utsu, T., 1966. A statistical significance test of the difference in b-value
between two earthquake groups, J. Phys. Earth, 14(2), 37–40.
Wiemer, S. & Wyss, M., 1997. Mapping the frequency-magnitude distribu tion in asperities:an improved technique to calculate recurrence times?, J.
geophys. Res., 102, 15 115–15 128.
Wiemer, S. & Wyss, M., 2000. Minimum magnitude of completeness in
earthquake catalogues: examples from Alaska, the Western United States,
and Japan, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 90(4), 859–869.
Wiemer, S. & Wyss, M., 2002. Mapping spatial variability of the frequency magnitude distribution of earthquakes, Adv. Geophys., 45, 259–302.
Wyss, M., 1973. Towards a physical understanding of the earthquake fre quency distribution, Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 31(4), 341–359.
Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. & Wang, T., 2017. Data completeness of the Ku mamoto earthquake sequence in the JMA catalogue and its influence
on the estimation of the ETAS parameters, Earth, Planets Space, 69,
1880–5981.
−bm and its confidence limits, Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst., Univ. Tokyo, 43,
237–239.
Amitrano, D., 2003. Brittle-ductile transition and associated seismicity: ex perimental and numerical studies and relationship with the b value, J.
geophys. Res., 108(B1), doi:10.1029/2001JB000680.
Amorese ` , D., 2007. Applying a change-point detection method on
frequency-magnitude distributions, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 97(5), 1742–
1749.
Bottiglieri, M., Lippiello, E., Godano, C. & de Arcangelis, L., 2009. Identi fication and spatiotemporal organization of aftershocks, J. geophys. Res.,
114(B3), doi:10.1029/2008JB005941.
Cao, A. & Gao, S.S., 2002. Temporal variation of seismic b-values beneath
northeastern Japan island arc, Geophys. Res. Lett., 29(9), 48–1-48-3.
de Arcangelis, L., Godano, C., Grasso, J.R. & Lippiello, E., 2016. Statistical
physics approach to earthquake occurrence and forecasting, Phys. Rep.,
628, 1–91 .
de Arcangelis, L., Godano, C. & Lippiello, E., 2018. The overlap of after shock coda-waves and short-term post seismic forecasting, J. geophys.
Res., 123(7), 5661–5674.
Garcia-Hernandez, R., D Auria, L., Barrancos, J., Padilla, G.D. & Perez,
N.M., 2021. Multiscale temporal and spatial estimation of the b-value,
Seismol. Res. Lett., 92(6), 3712–3724.
Godano, C., 2017. A new method for the estimation of the completeness
magnitude, Phys. Earth planet. Inter., 263, 7–11.
Godano, C. & Petrillo, G., 2022. Estimating the completeness mag nitude mc and the b-values in a snap, Earth Space Sci., 10(2),
doi:10.1029/2022EA002540.
Godano, C., Lippiello, E. & de Arcangelis, L., 2014. Variability of the
b value in the Gutenberg–Richter distribution, Geophys. J. Int., 199(3),
1765–1771.
Godano, C., Tramelli, A., Petrillo, G., Bellucci Sessa, E. & Lippiello, E.,
2022. The dependence on the Moho depth of the b-value of the Gutenberg Richter law, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 112(4), 1921–1934.
Gulia, L. & Wiemer, S., 2010. The influence of tectonic regimes on the
earthquake size distribution: a case study for Italy, Geophys. Res. Lett.,
37(10), doi:10.1029/2010GL043066.
Gulia, L. & Wiemer, S., 2019. Real-time discrimination of earthquake fore shocks and aftershocks., Nature, 574, 193–199.
Gutenberg, B. & Richter, C., 1944. Frequency of earthquakes in California,
, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 34, 185–188.
Hainzl, S., 2016a. Apparent triggering function of aftershocks resulting
from rate–dependent incompleteness of earthquake catalogues, J. geo phys. Res., 121(9), 6499–6509.
Hainzl, S., 2016b. Rate-dependent incompleteness of earthquake catalogues,
Seismol. Res. Lett., 87(2A), 337–344.
Hauksson, E., Yang, W. & Shearer, P.M., 2012. Waveform relocated earth quake catalogue for Southern California (1981 to June 2011), Bull. seism.
Soc. Am., 102(5), 2239–2244.
Helmstetter, A., Kagan, Y.Y. & Jackson, D.D., 2006. Comparison of short term and time-independent earthquake forecast models for Southern Cal ifornia, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 96(1), 90–106.
Herrmann, M. & Marzocchi, W., 2021. Inconsistencies and lurking pitfalls
in the magnitude frequency distribution of high-resolution earthquake
catalogues, Seismol. Res. Lett., 92(2A), 909–922.
Kagan, Y.Y., 2004. Short-term properties of earthquake catalogues and mod els of earthquake source, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 94(4), 1207–1228.
Lippiello, E., de Arcangelis, L. & Godano, C., 2008. Influence of time and
space correlations on earthquake magnitude, Phys. Rev. Lett., 100(3),
doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.100.038501.
Lippiello, E., Godano, C. & de Arcangelis, L., 2012. The earthquake mag nitude is influenced by previous seismicity, Geophys. Res. Lett., 39(5),
doi:10.1029/2012GL051083.
Lippiello, E., Petrillo, G., Landes, F. & Rosso, A., 2019. Fault heterogeneity
and the connection between aftershocks and afterslip, Bull. seism. Soc.
Am., 109(3), 1156–1163.
Lippiello, E., Petrillo, G., Landes, F. & Rosso, A., 2021. The genesis of
aftershocks in spring slider models, in Statistical Methods and Modeling
of Seismogenesis, Chapter 5, pp. 131–151, Wiley.
Marzocchi, W., Spassiani, I., Stallone, A. & Taroni, M., 2019a. How to be
fooled searching for significant variations of the b-value, Geophys. J. Int.,
220(3), 1845–1856.
Marzocchi, W., Spassiani, I., Stallone, A. & Taroni, M., 2019b. How to be
fooled searching for significant variations of the b-value, Geophys. J. Int.,
220(3), 1845–1856.
Mignan, A., 2012. Functional shape of the earthquake frequency-magnitude
distribution and completeness magnitude, J. geophys. Res., 117(B8),
doi:10.1029/2012JB009347.
Mogi, K., 1962. Study of the elastic shocks caused by the fracture of hetero geneous materials and itsrelation to earthquake phenomena, Bull. Earthq.
Res. Inst. Tokyo Univ., 40, 125–173.
Nanjo, K., 2020. Were changesin stressstate responsible for the 2019 Ridge crest, California, earthquakes?, Nat. Commun., 11, doi:10.1038/s41467-
020-16867-5.
Nanjo, K.Z., Hirata, N., Obara, K. & Kasahara, K., 2012. Decade-scale
decrease in b value prior to the M9-class 2011 Tohoku and 2004 Sumatra
quakes, Geophys. Res. Lett., 39(20), doi:10.1029/2012GL052997.
Nava, F.A., Marquez-Ram ´ ´ırez, V.H., Zuniga, ˜ F.R., Avila-Barrientos, ´ L. &
Quinteros, C.B., 2016. Gutenberg-Richter b-value maximum likelihood
estimation and sample size, J. Seismol., 21, 127–135.
Ogata, Y. & Katsura, K., 1993. Analysis of temporal and spatial hetero geneity of magnitude frequency distribution inferred from earthquake
catalogues, Geophys. J. Int., 113(3), 727–738.
Ogata, Y. & Yamashina, K., 1986. Unbiased estimate for b-value of magni tude frequency, J. Phys. Earth, 34(2), 187–194.
Omi, T., Ogata, Y., Hirata, Y. & Aihara, K., 2013. Forecasting large
aftershocks within one day after the main shock, Sci. Rep., 3,
doi:10.1038/srep02218.
Omi, T., Ogata, Y., Shiomi, K., Enescu, B., Sawazaki, K. & Aihara, K., 2016.
Automatic aftershock forecasting: a test using real-time seismicity data
in Japan, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 106(6), 2450–2458.
Peng, Z., Vidale, J.E., Ishii, M. & Helmstetter, A., 2007. Seismicity rate im mediately before and after main shock rupture from high-frequency wave forms in Japan, J. geophys. Res., 112(B3), doi:10.1029/2006JB004386.
Petrillo, G., Landes, F., Lippiello, E. & Rosso, A., 2020. The influence of
the brittle-ductile transition zone on aftershock and foreshock occurrence,
Nat. Commun., 11, 1–10.
Petruccelli, A., Schorlemmer, D., Tormann, T., Rinaldi, A., Wiemer, S.,
Gasperini, P. & Vannucci, G., 2019. The influence of faulting style on
the size-distribution of global earthquakes, Earth planet. Sci. Lett., 527,
doi:10.1016/j.epsl.2019.115791.
Rydelek, P.A. & Sacks, I.S., 2001. Migration of large earthquakes along the
San Jacinto Fault; stress diffusion from the 1857 Fort Tejon earthquake,
Geophys. Res. Lett., 28(16), 3079–3082.
Scholz, C., 1968. The frequency-magnitude relation of microfracturing in
rock and its relation to earthquakes, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 58, 399–415.
Scholz, C.H., 2015. On the stress dependence of the earthquake b value,
Geophys. Res. Lett., 42(5), 1399–1402.
Schorlemmer, D. & Woessner, J., 2008. Probability of detecting an earth quake, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 98(5), 2103–2117.
Shi, Y. & Bolt, B.A., 1982. The standard error of the magnitude-frequency
b value, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 72(5), 1677–1687.
Tormann, T., Wiemer, S. & Mignan, A., 2014. Systematic survey of high resolution b value imaging along Californian faults: inference on asperi ties, J. geophys. Res., 119(3), 2029–2054.
Tormann, T., Enescu, B., Woessner, J. & Wiemer, S., 2015. Randomness of
megathrust earthquakes implied by rapid stress recovery after the Japan
earthquake, Nat. Geosci., 8, 152–158.
Tramelli, A., Godano, C., Ricciolino, P., Giudicepietro, F., Caliro, S.,
Orazi, M., De Martino, P. & Chiodini, G., 2021. Statistics of seismic ity to investigate the Campi Flegrei caldera unrest, Sci. Rep., 11(1),
doi:10.1038/s41598-021-86506-6.
Utsu, T., 1966. A statistical significance test of the difference in b-value
between two earthquake groups, J. Phys. Earth, 14(2), 37–40.
Wiemer, S. & Wyss, M., 1997. Mapping the frequency-magnitude distribu tion in asperities:an improved technique to calculate recurrence times?, J.
geophys. Res., 102, 15 115–15 128.
Wiemer, S. & Wyss, M., 2000. Minimum magnitude of completeness in
earthquake catalogues: examples from Alaska, the Western United States,
and Japan, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 90(4), 859–869.
Wiemer, S. & Wyss, M., 2002. Mapping spatial variability of the frequency magnitude distribution of earthquakes, Adv. Geophys., 45, 259–302.
Wyss, M., 1973. Towards a physical understanding of the earthquake fre quency distribution, Geophys. J. R. astr. Soc., 31(4), 341–359.
Zhuang, J., Ogata, Y. & Wang, T., 2017. Data completeness of the Ku mamoto earthquake sequence in the JMA catalogue and its influence
on the estimation of the ETAS parameters, Earth, Planets Space, 69,
1880–5981.
Type
article
File(s)![]()
Name
ggad466.pdf
Description
Open Access Published Article
Size
1.63 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
59c0c716f6c37b12a865ea6a9847d209
