What we can say (or not) about the seismic sequence of the November 9th 2022, Mw 5.5, earthquake in the Marche offshore: an analysis of the Italian Seismic Bulletin on phase interpretation, velocity models and uncertainties of earthquake locations
Author(s)
Type
Conference paper
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
4T. Sismicità dell'Italia
Status
Published
Date Issued
February 9, 2023
Conference Location
Bologna, Italy
Subjects
Subjects
Abstract
Introduction
In November 2022 a seismic sequence occurred in the Marche offshore, about 29 km from the coast and the city of Fano. The sequence started on November 9 (06:07:25 UTC) with a ML=5.7 earthquake (Mw=5.5 from TDMD computation, Scognamiglio et al., 2006), immediately followed by a ML=5.2 earthquake (06:08:29 UTC) located about 8 km to the south. The two mainshocks activated a seismic sequence with about 400 aftershocks lasting the first week, 13 of them with ML>= 3.5 (Fig. 1).
Few hours after the occurrence of the mainshock, the BSI (“Bollettino Sismico Italiano”) working group started to manually analyze P and S phase arrival times and seismogram amplitudes of earthquakes with magnitude ML>= 3.5 recorded by the the Italian National Seismic Network (Rete Sismica Nazionale, hereafter RSN) in order to better constrain hypocenter locations previously provided by the seismic surveillance room of the INGV in Rome for rapid communication to the Italian Civil Protection (Dipartimento Protezione Civile, DPC). Later, the BSI working group analyzed the seismicity of the sequence of the first weeks of seismic activity by revising hypocentral parameters of more than 500 events.
The 2022 Marche offshore sequence took place along the Adriatic outer front of the northern Apennines in central Italy. Offshore seismic reflection profiles image a shallow thrust-and-fold system striking WNW–ESE to NNW–SSE. Along the coastal Adriatic area, active blind thrusts deform Plio-Quaternary siliciclastic turbidites that are few hundreds of meters to more than 2 km thick in correspondence of ramp anticlines and synclines, respectively. In a recent work, through the analysis of high-quality background seismicity data, De Nardis et al. (2022) identified two lithospheric-scale active thrusts deepening westward under the Adriatic outer front from upper- to lower-crustal depths. These new data support previous thick-skinned interpretations of seismic commercial profiles and CROP03 deep reflection data (Lavecchia et al., 2003). Focal mechanisms of weak to moderate (ML < 4.8) local earthquakes occurred between 2009-2017 at upper- to deep-crustal depths show prevailing reverse and reverse/oblique solutions (De Nardis et al., 2022) and subordinate strike-slip faulting (Mazzoli et al., 2014).
The analysis of the 2022 Marche offshore sequence opens again the discussion on the uncertainties related to the hypocenter locations of earthquakes that occur in the Adriatic offshore domain (e.g., Di Stefano et al., 2022) and the limits of our present capability to provide an accurate seismotectonic interpretation of the instrumental seismicity in this region. Actually, the 2022 sequence area is only covered on land by RSN, with the closest seismic station located at about 28 km from the epicentral location of the mainshock. The particular geometry of the network along the Italian coast makes it difficult to correctly constrain hypocenter locations compared with other regions of Italy. Taking into account this configuration, although the INGV is able to obtain coherent earthquake information for Civil Protection purposes into the limits of the communication threshold, we note that data provided by the seismic surveillance room in terms of both seismic phase readings of arrival times for hypocenter location and waveform amplitudes for magnitude computation need to a more accurate analysis if the main goal is the correct reconstruction of the active structures involved in the sequence. This analysis should include a) a careful revision of the arrival time pickings to reduce the errors due to seismic phase misinterpretations, b) an accurate study to constrain earthquake locations with appropriate velocity models, and c) the hypocenter solution assessment through adequate tests that define which information can be inferred from earthquake location results.
Data analysis and phases interpretation
Through the interpretation of the seismic records, the BSI analysts have identified refracted first arrivals of P and S phases at epicentral distances of about 60 km, smaller than those expected for Pn/Sn refracted phases at the Moho discontinuity (e.g., Di Stefano and Ciaccio, 2014) whose arrivals should be observed at distances of about 90-100 km in this area. Since possible systematic misinterpretation of P and S arrivals can strongly affect the correct hypocenter locations, we have carefully revised the phase pickings provided by the INGV surveillance room by discriminating direct from refracted phases at stations located at distances greater than 60 km. This is mainly important for interpretation of weak S refracted phases that are often hidden into the arrivals after the P phase. We have taken into account these characteristics in the earthquake location process by only using clear direct/refracted S phases in our inversion procedure. The comparison of the ML>= 3.5 hypocenter locations performed by the BSI and the INGV surveillance room (Figs. 1 and 2) shows how an accurate analysis of the pickings is necessary to obtain robust earthquake locations for seismotectonic interpretation: even using the same hypocenter location code and velocity model, we observe that the mislocation of the hypocenters in this area can range from few to about 10 kilometers (Fig. 1) while the formal errors are strongly reduced after the BSI picking revision (Fig. 2)
The velocity model issue
Events location in the Adriatic Sea suffers from the lack of a specific velocity model for the seismic sequence area. The use of inadequate velocity parameters during the location process can introduce systematic errors, which may result in incorrect seismotectonic interpretations. We therefore built and tested different velocity models from both available geophysical data and our inversion of the velocity structure using the arrival time readings revised by the BSI working group.
In order to define deterministic 1D models suitable for earthquake location (Vp and Vp/Vs), we integrated sonic logs from local deep wells (ViDEPI Project, 2005) with literature data that include: seismic commercial profiles, deep seismic refraction surveys, the CROP03 crustal profile, Receiver Function and regional seismic tomography models, Vp/Vs reference values for mid- and lower-crustal crystalline rocks (Coward et al., 1999; Ponziani et al., 1995; Lavecchia et al., 2003; Spada et al., 2013; Di Stefano et al., 2009, Christiansen and Mooney, 1993).
In order to obtain the velocity structure from our revised dataset, we first determined the Vp/Vs ratio by using the arrival time pickings of selected P and S phases. The mean velocity ratio Vp/Vs was computed through the cumulative Wadati diagram. Then, by collecting all the a priori available information regarding the structure of Adriatic Sea (velocities, layer thicknesses and Moho depth), we applied the VELEST software (Kissling, 1995) to compute a new 1D velocity model for earthquake location.
Conclusions
In this work we present our first analyses of the sequence and the accurate study of the velocity models that we obtained from both a revision of available data and the inversion of arrival time pickings analyzed by the BSI analists. Moreover, we will discuss our preliminary earthquake locations with a particular attention to resolution analysis and hypocenter location assessment.
In November 2022 a seismic sequence occurred in the Marche offshore, about 29 km from the coast and the city of Fano. The sequence started on November 9 (06:07:25 UTC) with a ML=5.7 earthquake (Mw=5.5 from TDMD computation, Scognamiglio et al., 2006), immediately followed by a ML=5.2 earthquake (06:08:29 UTC) located about 8 km to the south. The two mainshocks activated a seismic sequence with about 400 aftershocks lasting the first week, 13 of them with ML>= 3.5 (Fig. 1).
Few hours after the occurrence of the mainshock, the BSI (“Bollettino Sismico Italiano”) working group started to manually analyze P and S phase arrival times and seismogram amplitudes of earthquakes with magnitude ML>= 3.5 recorded by the the Italian National Seismic Network (Rete Sismica Nazionale, hereafter RSN) in order to better constrain hypocenter locations previously provided by the seismic surveillance room of the INGV in Rome for rapid communication to the Italian Civil Protection (Dipartimento Protezione Civile, DPC). Later, the BSI working group analyzed the seismicity of the sequence of the first weeks of seismic activity by revising hypocentral parameters of more than 500 events.
The 2022 Marche offshore sequence took place along the Adriatic outer front of the northern Apennines in central Italy. Offshore seismic reflection profiles image a shallow thrust-and-fold system striking WNW–ESE to NNW–SSE. Along the coastal Adriatic area, active blind thrusts deform Plio-Quaternary siliciclastic turbidites that are few hundreds of meters to more than 2 km thick in correspondence of ramp anticlines and synclines, respectively. In a recent work, through the analysis of high-quality background seismicity data, De Nardis et al. (2022) identified two lithospheric-scale active thrusts deepening westward under the Adriatic outer front from upper- to lower-crustal depths. These new data support previous thick-skinned interpretations of seismic commercial profiles and CROP03 deep reflection data (Lavecchia et al., 2003). Focal mechanisms of weak to moderate (ML < 4.8) local earthquakes occurred between 2009-2017 at upper- to deep-crustal depths show prevailing reverse and reverse/oblique solutions (De Nardis et al., 2022) and subordinate strike-slip faulting (Mazzoli et al., 2014).
The analysis of the 2022 Marche offshore sequence opens again the discussion on the uncertainties related to the hypocenter locations of earthquakes that occur in the Adriatic offshore domain (e.g., Di Stefano et al., 2022) and the limits of our present capability to provide an accurate seismotectonic interpretation of the instrumental seismicity in this region. Actually, the 2022 sequence area is only covered on land by RSN, with the closest seismic station located at about 28 km from the epicentral location of the mainshock. The particular geometry of the network along the Italian coast makes it difficult to correctly constrain hypocenter locations compared with other regions of Italy. Taking into account this configuration, although the INGV is able to obtain coherent earthquake information for Civil Protection purposes into the limits of the communication threshold, we note that data provided by the seismic surveillance room in terms of both seismic phase readings of arrival times for hypocenter location and waveform amplitudes for magnitude computation need to a more accurate analysis if the main goal is the correct reconstruction of the active structures involved in the sequence. This analysis should include a) a careful revision of the arrival time pickings to reduce the errors due to seismic phase misinterpretations, b) an accurate study to constrain earthquake locations with appropriate velocity models, and c) the hypocenter solution assessment through adequate tests that define which information can be inferred from earthquake location results.
Data analysis and phases interpretation
Through the interpretation of the seismic records, the BSI analysts have identified refracted first arrivals of P and S phases at epicentral distances of about 60 km, smaller than those expected for Pn/Sn refracted phases at the Moho discontinuity (e.g., Di Stefano and Ciaccio, 2014) whose arrivals should be observed at distances of about 90-100 km in this area. Since possible systematic misinterpretation of P and S arrivals can strongly affect the correct hypocenter locations, we have carefully revised the phase pickings provided by the INGV surveillance room by discriminating direct from refracted phases at stations located at distances greater than 60 km. This is mainly important for interpretation of weak S refracted phases that are often hidden into the arrivals after the P phase. We have taken into account these characteristics in the earthquake location process by only using clear direct/refracted S phases in our inversion procedure. The comparison of the ML>= 3.5 hypocenter locations performed by the BSI and the INGV surveillance room (Figs. 1 and 2) shows how an accurate analysis of the pickings is necessary to obtain robust earthquake locations for seismotectonic interpretation: even using the same hypocenter location code and velocity model, we observe that the mislocation of the hypocenters in this area can range from few to about 10 kilometers (Fig. 1) while the formal errors are strongly reduced after the BSI picking revision (Fig. 2)
The velocity model issue
Events location in the Adriatic Sea suffers from the lack of a specific velocity model for the seismic sequence area. The use of inadequate velocity parameters during the location process can introduce systematic errors, which may result in incorrect seismotectonic interpretations. We therefore built and tested different velocity models from both available geophysical data and our inversion of the velocity structure using the arrival time readings revised by the BSI working group.
In order to define deterministic 1D models suitable for earthquake location (Vp and Vp/Vs), we integrated sonic logs from local deep wells (ViDEPI Project, 2005) with literature data that include: seismic commercial profiles, deep seismic refraction surveys, the CROP03 crustal profile, Receiver Function and regional seismic tomography models, Vp/Vs reference values for mid- and lower-crustal crystalline rocks (Coward et al., 1999; Ponziani et al., 1995; Lavecchia et al., 2003; Spada et al., 2013; Di Stefano et al., 2009, Christiansen and Mooney, 1993).
In order to obtain the velocity structure from our revised dataset, we first determined the Vp/Vs ratio by using the arrival time pickings of selected P and S phases. The mean velocity ratio Vp/Vs was computed through the cumulative Wadati diagram. Then, by collecting all the a priori available information regarding the structure of Adriatic Sea (velocities, layer thicknesses and Moho depth), we applied the VELEST software (Kissling, 1995) to compute a new 1D velocity model for earthquake location.
Conclusions
In this work we present our first analyses of the sequence and the accurate study of the velocity models that we obtained from both a revision of available data and the inversion of arrival time pickings analyzed by the BSI analists. Moreover, we will discuss our preliminary earthquake locations with a particular attention to resolution analysis and hypocenter location assessment.
References
Christensen, N. I., and Mooney, W. D.; 1995: Seismic velocity structure and composition of the continental crust: A global view, J. Geophys. Res. 100, no. B6, 9761–9788.
Coward, M.P., De Donatis, M., Mazzoli, S., Paltrinieri, W., & Wezel, F.C.; 1999: Frontal part of the northern Apennines fold and thrust belt in the Romagna-Marche area (Italy): shallow and deep structural styles. Tectonics, 18 (3), 559–574.
De Nardis, R., Pandolfi, C., Cattaneo, M., Monachesi, G., Cirillo, D., Ferrarini, F., Bello, S., Brozzetti, F., & Lavecchia, G.; 2022: Lithospheric double shear zone unveiled by microseismicity in a region of slow deformation. Scientific Reports, (2022), 12:21066, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-24903-1.
Di Stefano, R., E. Kissling, C. Chiarabba, A. Amato, and Giardini, D.; 2009: Shallow subduction beneath Italy: Three-dimensional images of the Adriatic-European-Tyrrhenian lithosphere system based on high-quality P wave arrival times, J. Geophys. Res., 114, B05305, doi:10.1029/2008JB005641.
Di Stefano, R., Ciaccio M. G., Baccheschi P., Zhao D.; 2022: The Adriatic Thrust Fault of the 2021 Seismic Sequence Estimated from Accurate Earthquake Locations Using sP Depth Phases, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. XX, 1–14, DOI: 10.1785/0120220111
Kissling, E., 1995: Velest Users Guide, pp. 26, Internal report Institute of Geophysics, ETH Zurich.
Lavecchia, G., Boncio, P., & Creati, N.; 2003: A lithospheric-scale seismogenic thrust in central Italy. J. Geodyn., 36, 79–94. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0264- 3707(03)00040-1.
Mazzoli, S., Santini, S., Macchiavelli, C., and Ascione, A.; 2014: Active tectonics of the outer northern Apennines: Adriatic vs. Po Plain seismicity and stress fields, J. Geodyn. (2014), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jog.2014.10.002.
Ponziani, F., De Franco, R., Minelli, G., Biella, G., Federico, C., and Pialli, G.; 1995: Crustal shortening and duplication of the Moho in the Northern Apennines: a view from seismic refraction data: Tectonophysics, v. 252, p. 391–418.
Spada, M., I. Bianchi, E. Kissling, N. Piana Agostinetti, and Wiemer, S.; 2013: Combining controlled-source seismology and receiver function information to derive 3-D Moho topography for Italy, Geophys. J. Int., 194(2), 1050–1068, doi:10.1093/gji/ggt148.
ViDEPI Project; 2015: Visibility of petroleum exploration data in Italy. Ministry of Economic Development, National Mining Office for Hydrocarbons and Earth Resources - UNMIG. Well data and seismic reflection profiles available from: http://unmig.sviluppoeconomico.gov.it/videpi/videpi.asp.
Scognamiglio L., Tinti E. and Quintiliani M.; 2006: Time Domain Moment Tensor (TDMT) [Data set]. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (INGV), DOI https://doi.org/10.13127/TDMT
Coward, M.P., De Donatis, M., Mazzoli, S., Paltrinieri, W., & Wezel, F.C.; 1999: Frontal part of the northern Apennines fold and thrust belt in the Romagna-Marche area (Italy): shallow and deep structural styles. Tectonics, 18 (3), 559–574.
De Nardis, R., Pandolfi, C., Cattaneo, M., Monachesi, G., Cirillo, D., Ferrarini, F., Bello, S., Brozzetti, F., & Lavecchia, G.; 2022: Lithospheric double shear zone unveiled by microseismicity in a region of slow deformation. Scientific Reports, (2022), 12:21066, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-24903-1.
Di Stefano, R., E. Kissling, C. Chiarabba, A. Amato, and Giardini, D.; 2009: Shallow subduction beneath Italy: Three-dimensional images of the Adriatic-European-Tyrrhenian lithosphere system based on high-quality P wave arrival times, J. Geophys. Res., 114, B05305, doi:10.1029/2008JB005641.
Di Stefano, R., Ciaccio M. G., Baccheschi P., Zhao D.; 2022: The Adriatic Thrust Fault of the 2021 Seismic Sequence Estimated from Accurate Earthquake Locations Using sP Depth Phases, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. XX, 1–14, DOI: 10.1785/0120220111
Kissling, E., 1995: Velest Users Guide, pp. 26, Internal report Institute of Geophysics, ETH Zurich.
Lavecchia, G., Boncio, P., & Creati, N.; 2003: A lithospheric-scale seismogenic thrust in central Italy. J. Geodyn., 36, 79–94. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0264- 3707(03)00040-1.
Mazzoli, S., Santini, S., Macchiavelli, C., and Ascione, A.; 2014: Active tectonics of the outer northern Apennines: Adriatic vs. Po Plain seismicity and stress fields, J. Geodyn. (2014), http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jog.2014.10.002.
Ponziani, F., De Franco, R., Minelli, G., Biella, G., Federico, C., and Pialli, G.; 1995: Crustal shortening and duplication of the Moho in the Northern Apennines: a view from seismic refraction data: Tectonophysics, v. 252, p. 391–418.
Spada, M., I. Bianchi, E. Kissling, N. Piana Agostinetti, and Wiemer, S.; 2013: Combining controlled-source seismology and receiver function information to derive 3-D Moho topography for Italy, Geophys. J. Int., 194(2), 1050–1068, doi:10.1093/gji/ggt148.
ViDEPI Project; 2015: Visibility of petroleum exploration data in Italy. Ministry of Economic Development, National Mining Office for Hydrocarbons and Earth Resources - UNMIG. Well data and seismic reflection profiles available from: http://unmig.sviluppoeconomico.gov.it/videpi/videpi.asp.
Scognamiglio L., Tinti E. and Quintiliani M.; 2006: Time Domain Moment Tensor (TDMT) [Data set]. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (INGV), DOI https://doi.org/10.13127/TDMT
File(s)![]()
Name
1.1_Latorre_GNGTS_2023_BSI.pdf
Size
423.74 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
70607d083dcd062ef554701bd1798541
