Skip to main content
The search returned 6 results
Now showing 1 - 6 of 6
  • Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication, Access status: Restricted ,

    Reply to “Comment on ‘High-Definition Mapping of the Gutenberg–Richter b-Value and Its Relevance: A Case Study in Italy’ by M. Taroni, J. Zhuang, and W. Marzocchi” by Laura Gulia, Paolo Gasperini, and Stefan Wiemer

    Taroni et al. (2021; hereafter TZM21) proposed a method to perform a spatial b-value mapping based on the weighted-likelihood estimation and applied this method to the Italian region as a tutorial example. In the accompanying comment, Gulia et al. (2021; hereafter GGW21) did not challenge the TZM21’s method, but they argued that the catalog used by TZM21 is contaminated by quarry blasts, introducing a bias that may impact any seismotectonic or hazard interpretations. Although in TZM21 the application to the Italian territory was only a tutorial example and we purposely did not make any thorough discussion on the meaning of the results in terms of seismotectonic or seismic hazards (that would have required many more analyses), we acknowledge the potential role of the quarry blasts, and we add some further analysis here. We thank GGW21 for giving us this opportunity. Here, removing the part of the catalog contaminated by quarry blasts and applying the same analysis as in TZM21, we obtain results that are very similar to the ones reported in TZM21; specifically, only one region that is characterized by low natural seismicity rate shows a marked effect of the quarry blasts on the b-value.
      34  1
  • Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access ,

    Estimation of the Tapered Gutenberg-Richter Distribution Parameters for Catalogs with Variable Completeness: An Application to the Atlantic Ridge Seismicity

    The use of the tapered Gutenberg-Richter distribution in earthquake source models is rapidly increasing, allowing overcoming the definition of a hard threshold for the maximum magnitude. Here, we expand the classical maximum likelihood estimation method for estimating the parameters of the tapered Gutenberg-Richter distribution, allowing the use of a variable through-time magnitude of completeness. Adopting a well-established technique based on asymptotic theory, we also estimate the uncertainties relative to the parameters. Differently from other estimation methods for catalogs with a variable completeness, available for example for the classical truncated Gutenberg-Richter distribution, our approach does not need the assumption on the distribution of the number of events (usually the Poisson distribution). We test the methodology checking the consistency of parameter estimations with synthetic catalogs generated with multiple completeness levels. Then, we analyze the Atlantic ridge seismicity, using the global centroid moment tensor catalog, finding that our method allows better constraining distribution parameters, allowing the use more data than estimations based on a single completeness level. This leads to a sharp decrease in the uncertainties associated with the parameter estimation, when compared with existing methods based on a single time-independent magnitude of completeness. This also allows analyzing subsets of events, to deepen data analysis. For example, separating normal and strike-slip events, we found that they have significantly different but well-constrained corner magnitudes. Instead, without distinguishing for focal mechanism and considering all the events in the catalog, we obtain an intermediate value that is relatively less constrained from data, with an open confidence region.
      73  264
  • Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access ,

    High-Definition Mapping of the Gutenberg-Richter b-value and its Relevance: a Case Study in Italy

    The spatial variability of the magnitude-frequency distribution is important to improve earthquake forecasting capabilities at different time scales. Here, we develop a novel approach, based on the weighted maximum likelihood estimation, to build a spatial model for the b-value parameter of the Gutenberg-Richter law and its uncertainty, also for earthquake catalogs with a time-varying completeness magnitude. Then, we also provide a guideline based on the Bayes factor to measure the importance of the b-value spatial variability with respect to a model having a spatially uniform b-value. Finally, we apply the procedure to a new Italian instrumental earthquake catalog from 1960 to 2019 to investigate the b-value spatial variability over the Italian territory.
      166  214
  • Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access ,

    An extensive study of clustering features of seismicity in Italy from 2005 to 2016

    To study the characteristics of seismicity in Italy, we have made use of the ISIDE (Italian Seismic Instrumental and parametric Data-basE) catalogue since 2005 April 16, which was compiled by the Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (INGV). This catalogue includes high quality records of the occurrence times, locations, magnitude and other information about the earthquakes that occurred in and near Italy. We made use of the original form and two extended versions of the space–time ETAS model, namely, the 2-D ETAS model, the hypocentral 3-D ETAS model and the finite-source (FS) ETAS model. Our results show that the rupture geometries of large earthquakes, including the L’Aquila (2009 April 6 Mw6.1/ML5.9 ), the Finale-Emilia (2012 May 20, Mw5.8/ML5.9), the Amatrice (2016 August 24 Mw6.0/ML6.0) and the Norcia (2016 October 30 Mw6.5/ML6.1) earthquakes, control the spatial locations of their direct aftershocks. These direct aftershocks are mainly distributed in some areas adjacent to, but seldom at, the parts with the biggest slips along the main shock rupture, implying that aftershocks compensate the rupture of the main shock. The background seismicity rate is not stationary in all these areas, but shows several phases tuned by the major events. Regarding the difference among the three versions of the ETAS model, we found: (i) hypocentral depth plays an important role in triggering; (ii) when classifying background and triggered seismicity, all three models give similar results, but when classifying the family trees in the catalogue, the geometry of an earthquake rupture should be considered. The FS ETAS model classifies most aftershock events as aftershocks of the main shock; (iii) adopting point sources together with isotropic spatial response causes underestimates of the effects triggered by the main shocks. Such biases can be corrected by incorporating the rupture geometries of major events into the model formulation. Compared to the original point-source model, more direct aftershocks from the main shock are estimated by using the FS ETAS model and (iv) The rupture geometry of a major earthquake can be inverted to some extent from small aftershocks following it by fitting to the finite-source ETAS model.
      216  180
  • Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication, Access status: Restricted ,

    The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability: Achievements and Priorities

    The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability (CSEP) is a global cyberinfrastructure for prospective evaluations of earthquake forecast models and prediction algorithms. CSEP’s goals are to improve our understanding of earthquake predictability, advance forecasting model development, test key scientific hypotheses and their predictive power, and improve seismic hazard assessments. Since its inception in California in 2007, the global CSEP collaboration has been conducting forecast experiments in a variety of tectonic settings and at a global scale and now operates four testing centers on four continents to automatically and objectively evaluate models against prospective data. These experiments have provided a multitude of results that are informing operational earthquake forecasting systems and seismic hazard models, and they have provided new and, sometimes, surprising insights into the predictability of earthquakes and spurned model improvements. CSEP has also conducted pilot studies to evaluate ground-motion and hazard models. Here, we report on selected achievements from a decade of CSEP, and we present our priorities for future activities.
      88  2
  • Some of the metrics are blocked by your 
    Item type:Publication, Access status: Open Access ,

    Comprehensive and Topical Evaluations of Earthquake Forecasts in Terms of Number, Time, Space, and Magnitude

    Among scoring methods employed to determine the performance of probability predictions, the log-likelihood method is the most common and useful. Although the log-likelihood score evaluates the comprehensive power of forecasts, we need to further evaluate the topical predictive powers of respective factors of seismicity, such as total numbers, occurrence times, locations, and magnitudes. For this purpose, we used the conditional- or marginal-likelihood function based on the observed events. Such topical scores reveal both strengths and weaknesses of a forecasting model and suggest the necessary improvements. We applied these scores to the probability forecasts during the devastating period of March 2011, during which the Mw 9.0 Off the Pacific Coast of Tohoku-Oki earthquake struck. However, the evaluations did not suggest that any of the prospective forecast models were consistently satisfactory. Hence, we undertook two additional types of retrospective forecasting experiments to investigate the reasons, including the possibility that the seismicity rate pattern has changed after the M 9 mega-earthquake. In addition, our experiments revealed a technical difficulty in the one-day forecasting protocol adopted by the Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability (CSEP). Results of further experiments lead us to recommend specific modifications to the CSEP protocols, leading to real-time forecasts and their evaluations
      148  176