Experimental and numerical investigations on the seismic behaviour of the San Frediano bell tower in Lucca
Author(s)
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
5T. Sismologia, geofisica e geologia per l'ingegneria sismica
Status
Published
JCR Journal
JCR Journal
Peer review journal
Yes
Journal
Issue/vol(year)
3/62 (2019)
Publisher
INGV
Pages (printed)
SE342
Date Issued
February 11, 2019
Abstract
This paper presents a study on the seismic response of the San Frediano bell tower in Lucca. The tower’s ambient vibrations were con−
tinuously monitored for about one year, from October 2015 to October 2016. During this monitoring campaign, many seismic events were
recorded on the tower and the most relevant turned out to be the Amatrice earthquake, which struck Central Italy on 24 August 2016.
The paper begins with a review of the experimental results obtained. Then, a finite element numerical model of the tower is presented
and validated via model updating, by assuming the tower’s constituent materials to be unable to withstand tensile stresses. The exper−
imental records of the Amatrice earthquake are also included in the analysis to assess the dynamic behaviour of the finite element model
under ambient vibrations. Finally, a numerical simulation is performed of the tower subjected to the Lunigiana earthquake, recorded in
Fivizzano (Tuscany) on 21 June 2013: the results of the dynamic analysis are presented and discussed.
tinuously monitored for about one year, from October 2015 to October 2016. During this monitoring campaign, many seismic events were
recorded on the tower and the most relevant turned out to be the Amatrice earthquake, which struck Central Italy on 24 August 2016.
The paper begins with a review of the experimental results obtained. Then, a finite element numerical model of the tower is presented
and validated via model updating, by assuming the tower’s constituent materials to be unable to withstand tensile stresses. The exper−
imental records of the Amatrice earthquake are also included in the analysis to assess the dynamic behaviour of the finite element model
under ambient vibrations. Finally, a numerical simulation is performed of the tower subjected to the Lunigiana earthquake, recorded in
Fivizzano (Tuscany) on 21 June 2013: the results of the dynamic analysis are presented and discussed.
References
Acito M., M. Bocciarelli, C. Chesi and G. Milani (2014).
Collapse of the clock tower in Finale Emilia after
the May 2012 Emilia Romagna earthquake se−
quence: Numerical insight. Engineering Struc−
tures, 72, 70−91.
Azzara R.M., L. Zaccarelli A. Morelli., T. Trombetti G.
Dallavalle, A. Cavaliere and S. Danesi (2014). Seis−
mic monitoring of the Asinelli and Garisenda
medioeval towers in Bologna (Italy), an instrumental
contribution to the engineering modeling direct to
their protection. In F. M. Mazzolani & G. Altay (eds.),
Proceedings of the second International Conference
on Protection of Historical Constructions (PRO−
HITECH 2014). Proc. intern. symp., Antalya, Turkey,
May 7−9 2014. Istanbul: Boğaziçi University Pub−
lishing.
Azzara R.M., G. De Roeck, M. Girardi, C. Padovani, D. Pel−
legrini and E. Reynders (2016). Assessment of the
dynamic behaviour of an ancient masonry tower
in Lucca via ambient vibrations. Van Balen Koen,
Verstrynge Els, editors. Structural analysis of his−
torical constructions. anamnesis, diagnosis, ther−
apy, controls, Taylor & Francis Group, 2016, Print
ISBN: 978−1−138−02951−4 eBook ISBN: 978−1−
317−20662−0.
Azzara R. M., G. De Roeck, M. Girardi., C. Padovani, D.
Pellegrini and E. Reynders (2018). The influence of
environmental parameters on the dynamic behaviour of the San Frediano bell tower in Lucca.
Engineering Structures, 156, 175−187.
Barsocchi P., P. Cassara, F. Mavilia and D. Pellegrini (2018).
Sensing a City's State of Health: Structural Moni−
toring System by Internet−of−Things Wireless
Sensing Devices. IEEE Consumer Electronics Mag−
azine, 7(2), 22−31.
Bartoli G., M. Betti and S. Giordano (2013). In situ stat−
ic and dynamic investigations on the “Torre
Grossa” masonry tower. Engineering Structures, 52,
718−733.
Bartoli G., M. Betti, P. Biagini, A. Borghini, A. Ciavat−
tone, M. Girardi, G. Lancioni, A.M. Marra, B. Or−
tolani, B. Pintucchi and L. Salvatori (2017). Epis−
temic uncertainties in structural modeling: a blind
benchmark for seismic assessment of slender ma−
sonry towers. Journal of Performance of Constructed
Facilities 31(5), ASCE:
Bayraktar A., A. Şahin, D. M. Özcan and F. Yildirim,
(2010). Numerical damage assessment of Haghia
Sophia bell tower by nonlinear FE modeling. Ap−
plied Mathematical Modelling, 34(1), 92−121.
Bernardeschi K., C. Padovani and G. Pasquinelli (2004).
Numerical modelling of the structural behaviour of
Buti’s bell tower. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 5(4),
371−378.
Binante V., M. Girardi, C. Padovani, G. Pasquinelli, D. Pel−
legrini, M. Porcelli and L. Robol (2017). NOSA−ITA−
CA 1.1, cnr.isti/2017−SW−013, www.nosaitaca.it.
Bocciarelli M., and G. Barbieri (2017). A numerical pro−
cedure for the pushover analysis of masonry tow−
ers. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 93,
162−171.
Brincker R., and C. Ventura (2015). Introduction to Op−
erational Modal analysis, Wiley.
Cakir F., E. Uckan, J. Shen, S. Seker and B. Akbas (2016).
Seismic performance evaluation of slender masonry
towers: a case study. The Structural Design of Tall
And Special Buildings, 25(4), 193−212.
Callieri M., M. Corsini, M. Girardi, A. Pagni, C. Padovani,
G. Pasquinelli and R. Scopigno, (2010). The Rog−
nosa tower in San Gimignano: Digital acquisition
and structural analysis. Proceedings of the Tenth
International Conference on Computational Struc−
tures Technology, Civil−Comp Press.
Casolo S., (1998). A three−dimensional model for vul−
nerability analysis of slender medieval masonry
towers. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 2(4),
487−512.
Casolo S., G. Milani, G. Uva and C. Alessandri (2013).
Comparative seismic vulnerability analysis on ten
masonry towers in the coastal Po Valley in Italy. Engineering Structures, 49, 465−490.
Castellazzi G., A. M. D’Altri, S. de Miranda, A. Chiozzi
and A. Tralli (2018). Numerical insights on the seis−
mic behavior of a non−isolated historical mason−
ry tower. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering,
16(2), 933−961.
Cattari S., S. Degli Abbati, D. Ferretti, S. Lagomarsino,
D. Ottonelli and A.Tralli (2014). Damage assessment
of fortresses after the 2012 Emilia earthquake (Italy),
Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 12: 2333.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10518−013−9520−x.
Clough R.W. and Penzien J., (1975). Dynamics of Struc−
tures, Mc−Grow Hill, Inc.
D’Altri A. M., G. Castellazzi and S. de Miranda (2018).
Collapse investigation of the Arquata del Tronto
medieval fortress after the 2016 Central Italy
seismic sequence. Journal of Building Engineering,
18, 245−251.
D’Ambrisi A., V. Mariani and M. Mezzi (2012). Seismic
assessment of a historical masonry tower with non−
linear static and dynamic analyses tuned on am−
bient vibration tests. Engineering Structures, 36,
210−219.
De Falco A., M. Girardi and D. Pellegrini (2014). Non−
Linear Analyses on the Medieval “Ponte del Diavolo”
in Borgo a Mozzano (Italy). In B.H.V. Topping and
P. Iványi, (eds), Twelfth International Conference
on Computational Structures Technology; Proc. in−
tern. symp., Civil−Comp Press.
Degl’Innocenti S., C. Padovani and G. Pasquinelli (2006)
Numerical methods for the dynamic analysis of ma−
sonry structures, Structural Engineering and Me−
chanics, 22(1), 107−130.
Del Piero G., (1989). Constitutive equation and compat−
ibility of the external loads for linearly−elastic ma−
sonry−like materials. Meccanica, 24 pp.150−162.
Di Pasquale S., (1992). New trends in the analysis of ma−
sonry structures. Meccanica, 27, pp. 173−184.
D.M. 2018. Aggiornamento delle Norme Tecniche per le
Costruzioni, 17 gennaio 2018, G.U. 20 febbraio 2018,
n. 42.
D.P.C.M. 2011. Direttiva del Presidente del Consiglio dei
Ministri del 9 febbraio 2011: Valutazione e riduzione
del rischio sismico del patrimonio culturale con
riferimento alle Norme Tecniche per le Costruzioni
di cui al D. M. 14 gennaio 2008. G.U. n. 47 del 26
febbraio 2011– Suppl. ord. N. 54.
de Silva F., Pitilakis D., Ceroni F., Sica S., & Silvestri F.,
2018. Experimental and numerical dynamic iden−
tification of a historic masonry bell tower ac−
counting for different types of interaction. Soil Dy−
namics and Earthquake Engineering, 109, 235−250.
De Stefano A., E. Matta and P. Clemente (2016). Struc−
tural health monitoring of historical heritage in Italy:
some relevant experiences, Journal of Civil Struc−
tural Health Monitoring, 6(1), 83–106,
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13349−016−0154−y.
Ferraioli M., L. Miccoli, D. Abruzzese. and A. Mandara
(2017). Dynamic characterisation and seismic as−
sessment of medieval masonry towers. Natural Haz−
ards, 86(2), 489−515.
Gentile C. and A. Saisi (2007). Ambient vibration test−
ing of historic masonry towers for structural
identification and damage assessment. Construc−
tion and building materials, 21(6), 1311−1321.
Girardi, M., C. Padovani, and D. Pellegrini (2015). The
NOSA−ITACA code for the safety assessment of an−
cient constructions: a case study in Livorno. Adv
Eng Software, 89; 64–76.
Girardi, M., C. Padovani and D. Pellegrini, (2018).
Modal analysis of masonry structures. Mathemat−
ics and Mechanics of Solids, 1081286517751837.
Júlio E. N. B. S., C. A. da Silva Rebelo and D.A.S.G. Dias−
da Costa (2008). Structural assessment of the
tower of the University of Coimbra by modal iden−
tification. Engineering Structures, 30(12), 3468−
3477.
Karanikoloudis G. and P.B. Lourenço. (2018). Structural
assessment and seismic vulnerability of earthen his−
toric structures. Application of sophisticated nu−
merical and simple analytical models. Engineering
Structures, 160, 488−509.
Lourenco P.B., N. Mendes, R. Marques, 2009. Earthquake
Design and Assessment of Masonry Structures: Re−
view and Applications. In Trends in Civil and Struc−
tural Engineering Computing, Topping B.H.V.,
Costa Neves L.F., Bar−ros R.C. Eds, Saxe Coburg
Publications.
Lucchesi M., C. Padovani and A. Pagni (1994). A nu−
merical method for solving equilibrium problems
of masonry−like solids. Meccanica, 29(2), 175−193.
Lucchesi M. and B. Pintucchi (2007). A numerical mod−
el for non−linear dynamic analysis of slender ma−
sonry structures. European Journal of Mechanics
A/Solids, 26, 88−105.
Lucchesi M., C. Padovani, G. Pasquinelli. and N. Zani
(2008). Masonry constructions: mechanical mod−
els and numerical applications. Lecture Notes in Ap−
plied and Computational Mechanics, 39. Berlin,
Springer−Verlag.
Luzi L., F. Pacor, R. Puglia (2017). Italian Acceleromet−
ric Archive v 2.3. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e
Vulcanologia, Dipartimento della Protezione Civile
Nazionale. doi: 10.13127/ITACA.2.3.
Masciotta M.G., L.F. Ramos, P.B. Lourenço and M. Vas−
ta (2017). Damage Identification and Seismic Vul−
nerability Assessment of a Historic Masonry Chim−
ney. Annals of Geophysics, 60(4), 0442.
Milani G., S. Casolo, A. Naliato and A. Tralli (2012). Seis−
mic assessment of a medieval masonry tower in
Northern Italy by limit, nonlinear static, and full
dynamic analyses. International Journal of Archi−
tectural Heritage, 6(5), 489−524.
Minghini F., G. Milani and A. Tralli (2014). Seismic risk
assessment of a 50 m high masonry chimney us−
ing advanced analysis techniques. Engineering
Structures, 69, 255−270.
Padovani C., G. Pasquinelli and M. Šilhavý (2008). Pro−
cesses in masonry bodies and the dynamical sig−
nificance of collapse, Mathematics and Mechanics
of Solids, 13, 573−610.
Pellegrini D., M. Girardi, P.B. Lourenço, M.G. Masciotta,
N. Mendes, C. Padovani and L.F. Ramos (2018).
Modal analysis of historical masonry structures: Lin−
ear perturbation and software benchmarking. Con−
struction and Building Materials, 189, 1232−1250.
Pineda Palomo P., M.A. Gil Marti and M.D. Robador
González (2011). Seismic damage propagation pre−
diction in ancient masonry structures: an applica−
tion in the non−linear range via numerical mod−
els. Open Construction & Building Technology
Journal, 1−15.
Porcelli M., V. Binante, M. Girardi, C. Padovani, G.
Pasquinelli (2015). A solution procedure for con−
strained eigenvalue problems and its application
within the structural finite element code NOSA−ITA−
CA. Calcolo, 52:2, 167−186.
Preciado A., (2015). Seismic vulnerability and failure modes
simulation of ancient masonry towers by validat−
ed virtual finite element models. Engineering Fail−
ure Analysis, 57, 72−87.
Resta M., A. Fiore and P. Monaco (2013). Non−linear fi−
nite element analysis of masonry towers by adopt−
ing the damage plasticity constitutive model. Ad−
vances in Structural Engineering, 16(5), 791−803.
Reynders E., M. Schevenels. and G. De Roeck (2014).
MACEC 3.3. A Matlab toolbox for experimental and
opera−tional modal analysis. http://bwk.kuleu−
ven.be/bwm/macec/.
Reynders E., Maes K., G. Lombaert and G. De Roeck (2016).
Uncertainty quantification in operational modal
analysis with stochastic subspace identification: Val−
idation and applications. Mech. Syst. Signal Pro−
cess 66−67:13−30.
Sabia D., T. Aoki, R. M. Cosentini and R. Lancellotta (2015).
Model updating to forecast the dynamic behavior
of the Ghirlandina Tower in Modena, Italy. Jour−
nal of Earthquake Engineering, 19(1), 1−24.
Shakya M., H. Varum, R. Vicente and A. Costa (2018). Seis−
mic vulnerability assessment methodology for
slender masonry structures. International Journal of
Architectural Heritage, 1−30.
Ubertini F., N. Cavalagli, A. Kita and G. Comanducci (2018).
Assessment of a monumental masonry bell−tower
after 2016 Central Italy seismic sequence by long−
term SHM. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 16(2),
775−801.
Valente M. and G. Milani (2016a). Non−linear dynamic
and static analyses on eight historical masonry tow−
ers in the North−East of Italy. Engineering Struc−
tures, 114, 241−270.
Valente M. and G. Milani (2016b). Seismic assessment of
historical masonry towers by means of simplified
approaches and standard FEM. Construction and
Building Materials, 108, 74−104.
Zanotti Fragonara L., G. Boscato, R. Ceravolo, S. Rus−
so, S. Ientile, M.L. Pecorelli and A. Quattrone (2017).
Dynamic investigation on the Mirandola bell tow−
er in post−earthquake scenarios. Bulletin of Earth−
quake Engineering, 15(1), 313−337.
Collapse of the clock tower in Finale Emilia after
the May 2012 Emilia Romagna earthquake se−
quence: Numerical insight. Engineering Struc−
tures, 72, 70−91.
Azzara R.M., L. Zaccarelli A. Morelli., T. Trombetti G.
Dallavalle, A. Cavaliere and S. Danesi (2014). Seis−
mic monitoring of the Asinelli and Garisenda
medioeval towers in Bologna (Italy), an instrumental
contribution to the engineering modeling direct to
their protection. In F. M. Mazzolani & G. Altay (eds.),
Proceedings of the second International Conference
on Protection of Historical Constructions (PRO−
HITECH 2014). Proc. intern. symp., Antalya, Turkey,
May 7−9 2014. Istanbul: Boğaziçi University Pub−
lishing.
Azzara R.M., G. De Roeck, M. Girardi, C. Padovani, D. Pel−
legrini and E. Reynders (2016). Assessment of the
dynamic behaviour of an ancient masonry tower
in Lucca via ambient vibrations. Van Balen Koen,
Verstrynge Els, editors. Structural analysis of his−
torical constructions. anamnesis, diagnosis, ther−
apy, controls, Taylor & Francis Group, 2016, Print
ISBN: 978−1−138−02951−4 eBook ISBN: 978−1−
317−20662−0.
Azzara R. M., G. De Roeck, M. Girardi., C. Padovani, D.
Pellegrini and E. Reynders (2018). The influence of
environmental parameters on the dynamic behaviour of the San Frediano bell tower in Lucca.
Engineering Structures, 156, 175−187.
Barsocchi P., P. Cassara, F. Mavilia and D. Pellegrini (2018).
Sensing a City's State of Health: Structural Moni−
toring System by Internet−of−Things Wireless
Sensing Devices. IEEE Consumer Electronics Mag−
azine, 7(2), 22−31.
Bartoli G., M. Betti and S. Giordano (2013). In situ stat−
ic and dynamic investigations on the “Torre
Grossa” masonry tower. Engineering Structures, 52,
718−733.
Bartoli G., M. Betti, P. Biagini, A. Borghini, A. Ciavat−
tone, M. Girardi, G. Lancioni, A.M. Marra, B. Or−
tolani, B. Pintucchi and L. Salvatori (2017). Epis−
temic uncertainties in structural modeling: a blind
benchmark for seismic assessment of slender ma−
sonry towers. Journal of Performance of Constructed
Facilities 31(5), ASCE:
Bayraktar A., A. Şahin, D. M. Özcan and F. Yildirim,
(2010). Numerical damage assessment of Haghia
Sophia bell tower by nonlinear FE modeling. Ap−
plied Mathematical Modelling, 34(1), 92−121.
Bernardeschi K., C. Padovani and G. Pasquinelli (2004).
Numerical modelling of the structural behaviour of
Buti’s bell tower. Journal of Cultural Heritage, 5(4),
371−378.
Binante V., M. Girardi, C. Padovani, G. Pasquinelli, D. Pel−
legrini, M. Porcelli and L. Robol (2017). NOSA−ITA−
CA 1.1, cnr.isti/2017−SW−013, www.nosaitaca.it.
Bocciarelli M., and G. Barbieri (2017). A numerical pro−
cedure for the pushover analysis of masonry tow−
ers. Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 93,
162−171.
Brincker R., and C. Ventura (2015). Introduction to Op−
erational Modal analysis, Wiley.
Cakir F., E. Uckan, J. Shen, S. Seker and B. Akbas (2016).
Seismic performance evaluation of slender masonry
towers: a case study. The Structural Design of Tall
And Special Buildings, 25(4), 193−212.
Callieri M., M. Corsini, M. Girardi, A. Pagni, C. Padovani,
G. Pasquinelli and R. Scopigno, (2010). The Rog−
nosa tower in San Gimignano: Digital acquisition
and structural analysis. Proceedings of the Tenth
International Conference on Computational Struc−
tures Technology, Civil−Comp Press.
Casolo S., (1998). A three−dimensional model for vul−
nerability analysis of slender medieval masonry
towers. Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 2(4),
487−512.
Casolo S., G. Milani, G. Uva and C. Alessandri (2013).
Comparative seismic vulnerability analysis on ten
masonry towers in the coastal Po Valley in Italy. Engineering Structures, 49, 465−490.
Castellazzi G., A. M. D’Altri, S. de Miranda, A. Chiozzi
and A. Tralli (2018). Numerical insights on the seis−
mic behavior of a non−isolated historical mason−
ry tower. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering,
16(2), 933−961.
Cattari S., S. Degli Abbati, D. Ferretti, S. Lagomarsino,
D. Ottonelli and A.Tralli (2014). Damage assessment
of fortresses after the 2012 Emilia earthquake (Italy),
Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 12: 2333.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10518−013−9520−x.
Clough R.W. and Penzien J., (1975). Dynamics of Struc−
tures, Mc−Grow Hill, Inc.
D’Altri A. M., G. Castellazzi and S. de Miranda (2018).
Collapse investigation of the Arquata del Tronto
medieval fortress after the 2016 Central Italy
seismic sequence. Journal of Building Engineering,
18, 245−251.
D’Ambrisi A., V. Mariani and M. Mezzi (2012). Seismic
assessment of a historical masonry tower with non−
linear static and dynamic analyses tuned on am−
bient vibration tests. Engineering Structures, 36,
210−219.
De Falco A., M. Girardi and D. Pellegrini (2014). Non−
Linear Analyses on the Medieval “Ponte del Diavolo”
in Borgo a Mozzano (Italy). In B.H.V. Topping and
P. Iványi, (eds), Twelfth International Conference
on Computational Structures Technology; Proc. in−
tern. symp., Civil−Comp Press.
Degl’Innocenti S., C. Padovani and G. Pasquinelli (2006)
Numerical methods for the dynamic analysis of ma−
sonry structures, Structural Engineering and Me−
chanics, 22(1), 107−130.
Del Piero G., (1989). Constitutive equation and compat−
ibility of the external loads for linearly−elastic ma−
sonry−like materials. Meccanica, 24 pp.150−162.
Di Pasquale S., (1992). New trends in the analysis of ma−
sonry structures. Meccanica, 27, pp. 173−184.
D.M. 2018. Aggiornamento delle Norme Tecniche per le
Costruzioni, 17 gennaio 2018, G.U. 20 febbraio 2018,
n. 42.
D.P.C.M. 2011. Direttiva del Presidente del Consiglio dei
Ministri del 9 febbraio 2011: Valutazione e riduzione
del rischio sismico del patrimonio culturale con
riferimento alle Norme Tecniche per le Costruzioni
di cui al D. M. 14 gennaio 2008. G.U. n. 47 del 26
febbraio 2011– Suppl. ord. N. 54.
de Silva F., Pitilakis D., Ceroni F., Sica S., & Silvestri F.,
2018. Experimental and numerical dynamic iden−
tification of a historic masonry bell tower ac−
counting for different types of interaction. Soil Dy−
namics and Earthquake Engineering, 109, 235−250.
De Stefano A., E. Matta and P. Clemente (2016). Struc−
tural health monitoring of historical heritage in Italy:
some relevant experiences, Journal of Civil Struc−
tural Health Monitoring, 6(1), 83–106,
https://doi.org/10.1007/s13349−016−0154−y.
Ferraioli M., L. Miccoli, D. Abruzzese. and A. Mandara
(2017). Dynamic characterisation and seismic as−
sessment of medieval masonry towers. Natural Haz−
ards, 86(2), 489−515.
Gentile C. and A. Saisi (2007). Ambient vibration test−
ing of historic masonry towers for structural
identification and damage assessment. Construc−
tion and building materials, 21(6), 1311−1321.
Girardi, M., C. Padovani, and D. Pellegrini (2015). The
NOSA−ITACA code for the safety assessment of an−
cient constructions: a case study in Livorno. Adv
Eng Software, 89; 64–76.
Girardi, M., C. Padovani and D. Pellegrini, (2018).
Modal analysis of masonry structures. Mathemat−
ics and Mechanics of Solids, 1081286517751837.
Júlio E. N. B. S., C. A. da Silva Rebelo and D.A.S.G. Dias−
da Costa (2008). Structural assessment of the
tower of the University of Coimbra by modal iden−
tification. Engineering Structures, 30(12), 3468−
3477.
Karanikoloudis G. and P.B. Lourenço. (2018). Structural
assessment and seismic vulnerability of earthen his−
toric structures. Application of sophisticated nu−
merical and simple analytical models. Engineering
Structures, 160, 488−509.
Lourenco P.B., N. Mendes, R. Marques, 2009. Earthquake
Design and Assessment of Masonry Structures: Re−
view and Applications. In Trends in Civil and Struc−
tural Engineering Computing, Topping B.H.V.,
Costa Neves L.F., Bar−ros R.C. Eds, Saxe Coburg
Publications.
Lucchesi M., C. Padovani and A. Pagni (1994). A nu−
merical method for solving equilibrium problems
of masonry−like solids. Meccanica, 29(2), 175−193.
Lucchesi M. and B. Pintucchi (2007). A numerical mod−
el for non−linear dynamic analysis of slender ma−
sonry structures. European Journal of Mechanics
A/Solids, 26, 88−105.
Lucchesi M., C. Padovani, G. Pasquinelli. and N. Zani
(2008). Masonry constructions: mechanical mod−
els and numerical applications. Lecture Notes in Ap−
plied and Computational Mechanics, 39. Berlin,
Springer−Verlag.
Luzi L., F. Pacor, R. Puglia (2017). Italian Acceleromet−
ric Archive v 2.3. Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e
Vulcanologia, Dipartimento della Protezione Civile
Nazionale. doi: 10.13127/ITACA.2.3.
Masciotta M.G., L.F. Ramos, P.B. Lourenço and M. Vas−
ta (2017). Damage Identification and Seismic Vul−
nerability Assessment of a Historic Masonry Chim−
ney. Annals of Geophysics, 60(4), 0442.
Milani G., S. Casolo, A. Naliato and A. Tralli (2012). Seis−
mic assessment of a medieval masonry tower in
Northern Italy by limit, nonlinear static, and full
dynamic analyses. International Journal of Archi−
tectural Heritage, 6(5), 489−524.
Minghini F., G. Milani and A. Tralli (2014). Seismic risk
assessment of a 50 m high masonry chimney us−
ing advanced analysis techniques. Engineering
Structures, 69, 255−270.
Padovani C., G. Pasquinelli and M. Šilhavý (2008). Pro−
cesses in masonry bodies and the dynamical sig−
nificance of collapse, Mathematics and Mechanics
of Solids, 13, 573−610.
Pellegrini D., M. Girardi, P.B. Lourenço, M.G. Masciotta,
N. Mendes, C. Padovani and L.F. Ramos (2018).
Modal analysis of historical masonry structures: Lin−
ear perturbation and software benchmarking. Con−
struction and Building Materials, 189, 1232−1250.
Pineda Palomo P., M.A. Gil Marti and M.D. Robador
González (2011). Seismic damage propagation pre−
diction in ancient masonry structures: an applica−
tion in the non−linear range via numerical mod−
els. Open Construction & Building Technology
Journal, 1−15.
Porcelli M., V. Binante, M. Girardi, C. Padovani, G.
Pasquinelli (2015). A solution procedure for con−
strained eigenvalue problems and its application
within the structural finite element code NOSA−ITA−
CA. Calcolo, 52:2, 167−186.
Preciado A., (2015). Seismic vulnerability and failure modes
simulation of ancient masonry towers by validat−
ed virtual finite element models. Engineering Fail−
ure Analysis, 57, 72−87.
Resta M., A. Fiore and P. Monaco (2013). Non−linear fi−
nite element analysis of masonry towers by adopt−
ing the damage plasticity constitutive model. Ad−
vances in Structural Engineering, 16(5), 791−803.
Reynders E., M. Schevenels. and G. De Roeck (2014).
MACEC 3.3. A Matlab toolbox for experimental and
opera−tional modal analysis. http://bwk.kuleu−
ven.be/bwm/macec/.
Reynders E., Maes K., G. Lombaert and G. De Roeck (2016).
Uncertainty quantification in operational modal
analysis with stochastic subspace identification: Val−
idation and applications. Mech. Syst. Signal Pro−
cess 66−67:13−30.
Sabia D., T. Aoki, R. M. Cosentini and R. Lancellotta (2015).
Model updating to forecast the dynamic behavior
of the Ghirlandina Tower in Modena, Italy. Jour−
nal of Earthquake Engineering, 19(1), 1−24.
Shakya M., H. Varum, R. Vicente and A. Costa (2018). Seis−
mic vulnerability assessment methodology for
slender masonry structures. International Journal of
Architectural Heritage, 1−30.
Ubertini F., N. Cavalagli, A. Kita and G. Comanducci (2018).
Assessment of a monumental masonry bell−tower
after 2016 Central Italy seismic sequence by long−
term SHM. Bulletin of Earthquake Engineering, 16(2),
775−801.
Valente M. and G. Milani (2016a). Non−linear dynamic
and static analyses on eight historical masonry tow−
ers in the North−East of Italy. Engineering Struc−
tures, 114, 241−270.
Valente M. and G. Milani (2016b). Seismic assessment of
historical masonry towers by means of simplified
approaches and standard FEM. Construction and
Building Materials, 108, 74−104.
Zanotti Fragonara L., G. Boscato, R. Ceravolo, S. Rus−
so, S. Ientile, M.L. Pecorelli and A. Quattrone (2017).
Dynamic investigation on the Mirandola bell tow−
er in post−earthquake scenarios. Bulletin of Earth−
quake Engineering, 15(1), 313−337.
Type
article
File(s)![]()
Name
8025-22568-1-PB.pdf
Size
6.52 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
dbc8b20fedd9d62a7e44dc4d21735ab9
