Reply to ‘Comments on the paper “Are the source models of the M 7.1 1908 Messina Straits earthquake reliable? Insights from a novel inversion and sensitivity analysis of levelling data” by Aloisi et al. (2012)’
Author(s)
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
2T. Tettonica attiva
Status
Published
JCR Journal
JCR Journal
Peer review journal
Yes
Issue/vol(year)
/197 (2014)
Publisher
Oxford University Press
Pages (printed)
1403–1409
Date Issued
2014
Abstract
We reply to the comments of De Natale and Pino (2013) on the paper “Are the source models of the M 7.1 1908 Messina Straits earthquake reliable? Insights from a novel inversion and sensitivity analysis of levelling data” by Aloisi et al. (2012). We entirely reject their speculative comments and confirm our viewpoint about the impossibility of discriminating between the two oppositely dipping fault models on the basis of the levelling data alone; we state again that their role as a keystone for modellers is untenable. The comment of De Natale and Pino (2013) are welcomed insofar they give us the possibility to improve our previous analysis, and to criticize the mainstream hypothesis favoring to a low-angle East dipping fault in the Sicilian side of the Messina Straits as responsible of the 1908 destructive earthquake.
References
Aloisi, M., Bruno, V., Cannavò, F., Ferranti, L., Mattia, M., Monaco, C. & Palano, M., 2013. Are the source models of the M 7.1 1908 Messina Straits earthquake reliable? Insights from a novel inversion and a sensitivity analysis of levelling data, Geophys. J. Int., 192, 1025-1041, doi: 10.1093/gji/ggs062.
Amoruso, A., Crescentini, L. & Scarpa, R., 2002. Source parameters of the 1908 Messina Straits, Italy, earthquake from geodetic and seismic data, J.geophys. Res., 107, doi:10.1029/2001JB000434.
Anita, G., Sandri, L., Marzocchi, W., Argnani, A., Gasparini, P. & Selva, J., 2012. Probabilistic tsunami hazard assessment for Messina Strait Area (Sicily, Italy). Nat Hazards (2012) 64:329–358. DOI 10.1007/s11069-012-0246-x.
Argnani, A., Brancolini, G., Bonazzi, C., Rovere, M., Accaino, F., Zgur, F. & Lodolo, E., 2009. The result of the Taormina 2006 seismic survey: possible implications for active tectonics in the Messina Straits. Tectonophysics, 476, 159–169.
Baratta, M., 1910. La catastrofe sismica calabro-messinese (28 Dicembre 1908), Relazione alla Soc. Geogr. Ital.
Billi, A., Funiciello, R., Minelli, L., Faccenna, C., Neri, G., Orecchio, B. & Presti, D., 2008. On the cause of the 1908 Messina tsunami, southern Italy. Geophysical Research Letters 35, 6. doi:10.1029/2008GL033251.
Blumetti, A.M. et al., 2008. The environmental effects of the 1908 southern Calabria—Messina earthquake (southern Italy), in Riassunti estesi delle comunicazioni Convegno GNGTS 2008, Trieste, pp. 202–206.
De Stefani, C., 1910. La livellazione sul litorale calabro-siculo dopo il terremoto del 1908. Bollettino della Società geologica Italiana, 29, 223-231.
Ferranti, L., Monaco, C., Antonioli, F., Maschio, L., Kershaw, S.& Verrubbi, V. 2007. The contribution of regional uplift and coseismic slip to the vertical crustal motion in the Messina Straits, Southern Italy: evidence from raised Late Holocene shorelines, J. Geophys. Res., 112, B06401, doi: 10.1029/2006JB004473.
Ferranti, L., Monaco, C., Antonioli, F., Maschio, L., & Morelli, D., 2008a., Holocene activity of the Scilla fault, southern Calabria: insights from morpho-structural and marine geophysical data, Tectonophysics, 453, 74-93.
Ferranti, L., Monaco, C., Morelli, D., Tonielli, R., Tortorici, L., & Badalini, M., 2008b., Morphostructural setting and active faults in the Messina Strait: new evidence from marine geological data, Rend. online Soc. Geol. It., 1 , www.socgeol.it, 86-88.
Galli, P. & Bosi, V., 2002. Paleoseismology along the Cittanova fault: implications for seismotectonics and earthquake recurrence in Calabria (southern Italy). J. Geophys. Res. 107, B2044.
Ghisetti, F., 1984. Recent deformations and the seismogenic source in the Messina Straits (southern Italy), Tectonophysics, 109, 191–208.
Ghisetti, F., 1992. Fault parameters in the Messina Straits (southern Italy) and relations with the seismogenic source, Tectonophysics, 210, 117–133.
Jacques, E., Monaco, C., Tapponnier, P., Tortorici, L. & Winter, T., 2001. Faulting and earthquake triggering during the 1783 Calabria seismic sequence, Geophys. J. Int., 147, 499-516.
Loperfido, A., 1909. Livellazione geometrica di precisione eseguita dall’I.G.M. sulla costa orientale della Sicilia, da Messina a Catania, a Gesso ed a Faro Peloro e sulla costa occidentale della Calabria da Gioia Tauro a Melito di Porto Salvo, in Relazione della Commissione Reale incaricata di designare le zone pi`u adatte per la ricostruzione degli abitati colpiti dal terremoto del 28 dicembre 1908 o da altri precedenti, pp.131–156, Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Roma.
Monaco, C., & Tortorici, L., 2000. Active faulting in the Calabrian arc and eastern Sicily, J. Geodynamics, 29, 407-424.
Papanikolaou, I.D., & Roberts, G.P., 2007. Geometry, kinematics and deformation rates along the active normal fault system in the southern Apennines: Implications for fault growth. J. Struct. Geol., 29, 166-188.
Pino, N.A., Giardini, D. & Boschi, E., 2000. The December 28, 1908, Messina Straits, southern Italy, earthquake: waveform modeling of regional seismograms, J. geophys. Res., 105(B11), 25 473–25 492.
Pino, N.A., De Natale, G., 2013. Comment on ‘Are the source models of the M 7.1 1908 Messina Straits earthquake reliable? Insights from a novel inversion and sensitivity analysis of levelling data’ by M. Aloisi, V. Bruno, F. Cannavò, L. Ferranti, M. Mattia, C. Monaco and M. Palano, Geophys. J. Int., this volume.
Polonia, A., Torelli, L., Gasperini, L. & Mussoni, P., 2012. Active faults and historical earthquakes in the Messina Straits area (Ionian Sea). Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 12, 2311–2328.
Ridente, R., Martorelli, E., Bosman, A. & Chiocci, F.L., 2013. High-resolution morpho-bathymetric imaging of the Messina Strait (Southern Italy). New insights on the 1908 earthquake and tsunami. Geomorphology, in print. Rizzo, G. B., 1910. Sulla propagazione dei movimenti prodotti dal terremoto di Messina del 28 Dicembre 1908, Rend. Accad. Sci. Torino, Ser. II, LXI, 355– 417.
Rovida, A., Camassi, R., Gasperini, P. & Stucchi, M. (eds.), 2011. CPTI11, the 2011 version of the Parametric Catalogue of Italian Earthquakes. Milano, Bologna, http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI, DOI: 10.6092/INGV.IT-CPTI11
Scarfi’, L., Langer, H. & Scaltrito, A., 2009. Seismicity, seismotectonics and crustal velocity structure of theMessina Strait (Italy), Phys. Earth planet. Inter., 177, 65–78.
Tortorici, L., Monaco, C., Tansi, C. & Cocina, O., 1995. Recent and active tectonics in the Calabrian Arc (Southern Italy), Tectonophysics, 243, 37-49.
Valensise, G. & Pantosti, D., 1992. A 125-Kyr-long geological record of seismic source repeatability: the Messina Straits (southern Italy) and the 1908 earthquake (MS 7 1/2), Terra Nova, 4, 472–483.
Amoruso, A., Crescentini, L. & Scarpa, R., 2002. Source parameters of the 1908 Messina Straits, Italy, earthquake from geodetic and seismic data, J.geophys. Res., 107, doi:10.1029/2001JB000434.
Anita, G., Sandri, L., Marzocchi, W., Argnani, A., Gasparini, P. & Selva, J., 2012. Probabilistic tsunami hazard assessment for Messina Strait Area (Sicily, Italy). Nat Hazards (2012) 64:329–358. DOI 10.1007/s11069-012-0246-x.
Argnani, A., Brancolini, G., Bonazzi, C., Rovere, M., Accaino, F., Zgur, F. & Lodolo, E., 2009. The result of the Taormina 2006 seismic survey: possible implications for active tectonics in the Messina Straits. Tectonophysics, 476, 159–169.
Baratta, M., 1910. La catastrofe sismica calabro-messinese (28 Dicembre 1908), Relazione alla Soc. Geogr. Ital.
Billi, A., Funiciello, R., Minelli, L., Faccenna, C., Neri, G., Orecchio, B. & Presti, D., 2008. On the cause of the 1908 Messina tsunami, southern Italy. Geophysical Research Letters 35, 6. doi:10.1029/2008GL033251.
Blumetti, A.M. et al., 2008. The environmental effects of the 1908 southern Calabria—Messina earthquake (southern Italy), in Riassunti estesi delle comunicazioni Convegno GNGTS 2008, Trieste, pp. 202–206.
De Stefani, C., 1910. La livellazione sul litorale calabro-siculo dopo il terremoto del 1908. Bollettino della Società geologica Italiana, 29, 223-231.
Ferranti, L., Monaco, C., Antonioli, F., Maschio, L., Kershaw, S.& Verrubbi, V. 2007. The contribution of regional uplift and coseismic slip to the vertical crustal motion in the Messina Straits, Southern Italy: evidence from raised Late Holocene shorelines, J. Geophys. Res., 112, B06401, doi: 10.1029/2006JB004473.
Ferranti, L., Monaco, C., Antonioli, F., Maschio, L., & Morelli, D., 2008a., Holocene activity of the Scilla fault, southern Calabria: insights from morpho-structural and marine geophysical data, Tectonophysics, 453, 74-93.
Ferranti, L., Monaco, C., Morelli, D., Tonielli, R., Tortorici, L., & Badalini, M., 2008b., Morphostructural setting and active faults in the Messina Strait: new evidence from marine geological data, Rend. online Soc. Geol. It., 1 , www.socgeol.it, 86-88.
Galli, P. & Bosi, V., 2002. Paleoseismology along the Cittanova fault: implications for seismotectonics and earthquake recurrence in Calabria (southern Italy). J. Geophys. Res. 107, B2044.
Ghisetti, F., 1984. Recent deformations and the seismogenic source in the Messina Straits (southern Italy), Tectonophysics, 109, 191–208.
Ghisetti, F., 1992. Fault parameters in the Messina Straits (southern Italy) and relations with the seismogenic source, Tectonophysics, 210, 117–133.
Jacques, E., Monaco, C., Tapponnier, P., Tortorici, L. & Winter, T., 2001. Faulting and earthquake triggering during the 1783 Calabria seismic sequence, Geophys. J. Int., 147, 499-516.
Loperfido, A., 1909. Livellazione geometrica di precisione eseguita dall’I.G.M. sulla costa orientale della Sicilia, da Messina a Catania, a Gesso ed a Faro Peloro e sulla costa occidentale della Calabria da Gioia Tauro a Melito di Porto Salvo, in Relazione della Commissione Reale incaricata di designare le zone pi`u adatte per la ricostruzione degli abitati colpiti dal terremoto del 28 dicembre 1908 o da altri precedenti, pp.131–156, Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Roma.
Monaco, C., & Tortorici, L., 2000. Active faulting in the Calabrian arc and eastern Sicily, J. Geodynamics, 29, 407-424.
Papanikolaou, I.D., & Roberts, G.P., 2007. Geometry, kinematics and deformation rates along the active normal fault system in the southern Apennines: Implications for fault growth. J. Struct. Geol., 29, 166-188.
Pino, N.A., Giardini, D. & Boschi, E., 2000. The December 28, 1908, Messina Straits, southern Italy, earthquake: waveform modeling of regional seismograms, J. geophys. Res., 105(B11), 25 473–25 492.
Pino, N.A., De Natale, G., 2013. Comment on ‘Are the source models of the M 7.1 1908 Messina Straits earthquake reliable? Insights from a novel inversion and sensitivity analysis of levelling data’ by M. Aloisi, V. Bruno, F. Cannavò, L. Ferranti, M. Mattia, C. Monaco and M. Palano, Geophys. J. Int., this volume.
Polonia, A., Torelli, L., Gasperini, L. & Mussoni, P., 2012. Active faults and historical earthquakes in the Messina Straits area (Ionian Sea). Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci., 12, 2311–2328.
Ridente, R., Martorelli, E., Bosman, A. & Chiocci, F.L., 2013. High-resolution morpho-bathymetric imaging of the Messina Strait (Southern Italy). New insights on the 1908 earthquake and tsunami. Geomorphology, in print. Rizzo, G. B., 1910. Sulla propagazione dei movimenti prodotti dal terremoto di Messina del 28 Dicembre 1908, Rend. Accad. Sci. Torino, Ser. II, LXI, 355– 417.
Rovida, A., Camassi, R., Gasperini, P. & Stucchi, M. (eds.), 2011. CPTI11, the 2011 version of the Parametric Catalogue of Italian Earthquakes. Milano, Bologna, http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI, DOI: 10.6092/INGV.IT-CPTI11
Scarfi’, L., Langer, H. & Scaltrito, A., 2009. Seismicity, seismotectonics and crustal velocity structure of theMessina Strait (Italy), Phys. Earth planet. Inter., 177, 65–78.
Tortorici, L., Monaco, C., Tansi, C. & Cocina, O., 1995. Recent and active tectonics in the Calabrian Arc (Southern Italy), Tectonophysics, 243, 37-49.
Valensise, G. & Pantosti, D., 1992. A 125-Kyr-long geological record of seismic source repeatability: the Messina Straits (southern Italy) and the 1908 earthquake (MS 7 1/2), Terra Nova, 4, 472–483.
Type
article
File(s)![]()
Name
Aloisi et al., 2014_reply.pdf
Description
Main article
Size
4.97 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
72dba80cf7cdd40ac740662d13ae1020
