What scientific information on non-structural elements seismic risk people need to know? Part 1: Compiling an inventory on damage to non-structural elements
Author(s)
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
5T. Sismologia, geofisica e geologia per l'ingegneria sismica
Status
Published
JCR Journal
JCR Journal
Peer review journal
Yes
Journal
Issue/vol(year)
3/64 (2021)
ISSN
2037-416X
Electronic ISSN
2037-416X
Publisher
Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (INGV)
Pages (printed)
SE321
Date Issued
July 23, 2021
Subjects
Abstract
Understanding seismic damages to non-structural elements and their effects on functionality of facilities are important in developing general recommendations for earthquake risk management.
This paper presents a review of non-structural damage caused by recent earthquakes in Mt. Etna in Italy, Lisbon and Azores islands in Portugal and southern Lowland in Iceland. The study was performed as a part of the KnowRISK EU project. The objective of this review is to identify the most commonly damaged non-structural elements in these different areas. This is a basic requirement for preparing prevention strategies communication campaigns that are tailored to the local needs. This study shows that the most commonly damaged elements are partition walls, ceiling systems, non-structural vaults, chimneys, building contents and storage racks. Analyses proved that substantive efforts are needed worldwide to improve techniques for reducing damage to non-structural elements. The observations on frequency, severity, and consequences of damage of different non-structural elements are important for (i) making mitigation plans and priorities (ii) designing mitigation measures, and (iii) communicating the mitigation measures to different stakeholders. These activities aim to raise stakeholders’ awareness of potential risk and viable mitigation measures.
This paper presents a review of non-structural damage caused by recent earthquakes in Mt. Etna in Italy, Lisbon and Azores islands in Portugal and southern Lowland in Iceland. The study was performed as a part of the KnowRISK EU project. The objective of this review is to identify the most commonly damaged non-structural elements in these different areas. This is a basic requirement for preparing prevention strategies communication campaigns that are tailored to the local needs. This study shows that the most commonly damaged elements are partition walls, ceiling systems, non-structural vaults, chimneys, building contents and storage racks. Analyses proved that substantive efforts are needed worldwide to improve techniques for reducing damage to non-structural elements. The observations on frequency, severity, and consequences of damage of different non-structural elements are important for (i) making mitigation plans and priorities (ii) designing mitigation measures, and (iii) communicating the mitigation measures to different stakeholders. These activities aim to raise stakeholders’ awareness of potential risk and viable mitigation measures.
Sponsors
KnowRISK is co-financed by European Commission’s Humanitarian Aid and Civil Protection Grant agreement ECHO/SUB/2015/718655/PREV28. It is a project that involved four different European research centers and universities under the coordination of the Instituto Superior Técnico (Portugal). The partners are the Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia (Italy), the Laboratório Nacional de Engenharia Civil (Portugal) and the Earthquake Engineering Research Centre (University of Iceland). We acknowledge Antonio Torrisi, Department of Civil Protection of Sicily (DPCR)
– Unit of Seismic and Volcanic Risk S.03, for having provided data from AeDES forms. Rajesh Rupakhety acknowledges support from the University of Iceland research fund.
– Unit of Seismic and Volcanic Risk S.03, for having provided data from AeDES forms. Rajesh Rupakhety acknowledges support from the University of Iceland research fund.
References
Azzaro R., S. D’Amico S., T. Tuvè, M. Cascone (2016). Etnean earthquakes, seismic risk from non-structural elements. KnowRISK Project, 35 pp., Catania. (in english and italian)
Baggio C., Bernardini A., R. Colozza, L. Corazza, M. Della Bella, G. Di Pasquale, M. Dolce, A. Goretti, A. Martinelli, G. Orsini, F. Papa, G. Zuccaro (2002). Manuale per la compilazione della scheda di 1° livello di rilevamento danno, pronto intervento e agibilità per edifici ordinari nell’emergenza post-sismica (AeDES), Dipartimento della Protezione Civile, Roma, 111.
Baggio C., A. Bernardini A., R. Colozza, L. Corazza., M. Della Bella, G. Di Pasquale, M. Dolce, A. Goretti, A. Martinelli, G. Orsini, F. Papa, G. Zuccaro (2007). Field Manual for post-earthquake damage and safety assessment and short term countermeasures (AeDES), Editors: Pinto A.V., Taucer F., European Commission - Joint Research Centre, Institute for the Protection and Security of the Citizen - Scientific and Technical Reports, 100.
Bessason B., J.Ö. Bjarnason, A. Gudmundsson, J. Sólnes, S. Steedman (2012). Probabilistic Earthquake Damage Curves for Low-Rise Buildings Based on Field Data, Earthquake Spectra, 28, 4, 1353-1378.
Bessason B., JÖ. Bjarnason, A. Guðmundsson, J. Sólnes, S. Steedman (2014). Analysis of damage data of low-rise building subjected to a shallow Mw6.3 earthquake, Soil Dyn. Earthq. Engin., 66, 89-101
Bessason B., J.Ö. Bjarnason (2016). Seismic vulnerability of low-rise residential buildings based on damage data from three earthquakes (Mw 6.5, 6.5 and 6.3), Engineering Structures, 111, 64-79.
Bessason B, J.Ö. Bjarnason, R. Rupakhety (2020). Statistical modelling of seismic vulnerability of RC, timber and masonry buildings from complete empirical loss data, Engineering Structures, 209.
Dolce M., E. Speranza, F. Giordano, B. Borzi, F. Bocchi, C. Conte, A. Di Meo, M. Faravelli, V. Pascale (2017a). La piattaforma web-GIS DA.D.O. per la consultazione e la comparazione del danno osservato in eventi sismici di rilevanza nazionale dal 1976, 37° convegno nazionale del GNGTS, Bologna, 19-21 novembre 2018.
Dolce M., E. Speranza, F. Giordano, B. Borzi, F. Bocchi, C. Conte, A. Di Meo, M. Faravelli, V. Pascale (2017b). Da.D.O - Uno strumento per la consultazione e la comparazione del danno osservato relativo ai più significativi eventi sismici in Italia dal 1976, In: atti del XVII Convegno ANIDIS “L’ingegneria Sismica in Italia”. Pistoia, 17-21 Settembre 2017.
Ferreira, M.A. (2008). Classificação dos danos no edificado com base na EMS-98. Sismo 1998 - Açores. Uma década depois, Edição C.S. Oliveira, Aníbal Costa, João C. Nunes, Governo dos Açores/SPRHI, S.A., 501-512. (in portuguese).
Filiatrault A., J.T. Sullivan (2014). Performance-based seismic design of non-structural building components: The next frontier of earthquake engineering, J. Earth. Engin. Engin. Vibration. Special Issue on the State-of-the art and Future Challenges of Earthquake Engineering, 13, 1, 17–46, DOI:10.1007/s11803-014-0238-9.
Grünthal G. (Ed.) (1998). European Macroseismic Scale 1998 (EMS-98). European Seismological Commission, sub commission on Engineering Seismology, Working Group Macroseismic Scales. Conseil del’Europe, Cahiers du Conseil de l’Europe, Cahiers du Centre Européen de Géodynamique et de Séismologie, 15, Luxembourg.
Hemeroteca Digital. O Sismo de 1969 na imprensa portuguesa [Online], Available: http://hemerotecadigital.cm lisboa.pt/EFEMERIDES/Sismo1969/Sismo1969.htm [Consulted in April 2019], Hemeroteca Municipal de Lisboa.
ITERATE – Improved Tools for Disaster Risk Mitigation in Algeria, ECHO/SUB/2016/740181/PREV23, http://www.iterate-eu.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/DE3-NonStructural-Elements.pdf.
Neves, F., A. Costa, R. Vicente, C. S. Oliveira, H. Varum (2012). Seismic vulnerability assessment and characterisation of the buildings on Faial Island, Azores, Bull. Earthq. Engin., 10, 1, 27–44, DOI 10.1007/s10518-011-9276-0.
Neves, F., C.S. Oliveira, A. Costa (2008). Base de dados relativa ao parque habitacional da ilha do Faial e Pico, danos sofridos no sismo de 1998 e processo da reconstrução. “Sismo 1998 - Açores. Uma década depois”, C. Sousa Oliveira, Aníbal Costa, João C. Nunes (eds.), ISBN 978-989-20-1223-0. (41) 515-520.
O Século Ilustrado (1969). Retrieved from http://hemerotecadigital.cm-lisboa.pt/EFEMERIDES/Sismo1969/Sismo1969.htm
Oliveira C.S. (1982). The role of historical seismicity in the evaluation of seismic risk of Lisbon, Proceedings 7th European Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Athens.
Oliveira, C.S., M. A. Ferreira (2008). Impacto do sismo de 1998 no território dos Açores. Principais consequências e indicadores. Sismo 1998 - Açores. Uma década depois. Edição C. S. Oliveira, Aníbal Costa, João C. Nunes, Governo dos Açores/SPRHI, S.A., 717-726.
Solarino, S., M.A. Ferreira, G. Musacchio, R. Rupakhety, H. O’Neill, S. Falsaperla, M. Vicente, M. Lopes, C.S. Oliveira (2021). What scientific information on non-structural elements seismic risk do people need to know? Part 2 - tools for risk communication, Ann. Geophys., 64, (this issue).
Thorvaldsdóttir, S., B. Bessason (2018). Identification of the most vulnerable non-structural components in the pilot study area (Iceland case). KnowRISK project deliverable C2, available at https://knowriskproject.com/project reports/
Thorvaldsdóttir S, Bessason B, Rupakhety R (2021) Towards DRM for residential buildings, Ann. Geophys., 64, (this issue).
Torrisi, A. (2018). Esiti di Agibilità e Danno nell’Emergenza Sismica (schede AeDES) in occasione dei terremoti etnei del 2002 e 2008, Regione Siciliana, Dipartimento della Protezione Civile, Servizio Rischio Sismico e Vulcanico S.03, Nicolosi (Italy).
50 anos do sismo de 28 de Fevereiro de 1969 online, c2019-2020. http://sismo1969.ipma.pt/ [accessed in January 2020]
Baggio C., Bernardini A., R. Colozza, L. Corazza, M. Della Bella, G. Di Pasquale, M. Dolce, A. Goretti, A. Martinelli, G. Orsini, F. Papa, G. Zuccaro (2002). Manuale per la compilazione della scheda di 1° livello di rilevamento danno, pronto intervento e agibilità per edifici ordinari nell’emergenza post-sismica (AeDES), Dipartimento della Protezione Civile, Roma, 111.
Baggio C., A. Bernardini A., R. Colozza, L. Corazza., M. Della Bella, G. Di Pasquale, M. Dolce, A. Goretti, A. Martinelli, G. Orsini, F. Papa, G. Zuccaro (2007). Field Manual for post-earthquake damage and safety assessment and short term countermeasures (AeDES), Editors: Pinto A.V., Taucer F., European Commission - Joint Research Centre, Institute for the Protection and Security of the Citizen - Scientific and Technical Reports, 100.
Bessason B., J.Ö. Bjarnason, A. Gudmundsson, J. Sólnes, S. Steedman (2012). Probabilistic Earthquake Damage Curves for Low-Rise Buildings Based on Field Data, Earthquake Spectra, 28, 4, 1353-1378.
Bessason B., JÖ. Bjarnason, A. Guðmundsson, J. Sólnes, S. Steedman (2014). Analysis of damage data of low-rise building subjected to a shallow Mw6.3 earthquake, Soil Dyn. Earthq. Engin., 66, 89-101
Bessason B., J.Ö. Bjarnason (2016). Seismic vulnerability of low-rise residential buildings based on damage data from three earthquakes (Mw 6.5, 6.5 and 6.3), Engineering Structures, 111, 64-79.
Bessason B, J.Ö. Bjarnason, R. Rupakhety (2020). Statistical modelling of seismic vulnerability of RC, timber and masonry buildings from complete empirical loss data, Engineering Structures, 209.
Dolce M., E. Speranza, F. Giordano, B. Borzi, F. Bocchi, C. Conte, A. Di Meo, M. Faravelli, V. Pascale (2017a). La piattaforma web-GIS DA.D.O. per la consultazione e la comparazione del danno osservato in eventi sismici di rilevanza nazionale dal 1976, 37° convegno nazionale del GNGTS, Bologna, 19-21 novembre 2018.
Dolce M., E. Speranza, F. Giordano, B. Borzi, F. Bocchi, C. Conte, A. Di Meo, M. Faravelli, V. Pascale (2017b). Da.D.O - Uno strumento per la consultazione e la comparazione del danno osservato relativo ai più significativi eventi sismici in Italia dal 1976, In: atti del XVII Convegno ANIDIS “L’ingegneria Sismica in Italia”. Pistoia, 17-21 Settembre 2017.
Ferreira, M.A. (2008). Classificação dos danos no edificado com base na EMS-98. Sismo 1998 - Açores. Uma década depois, Edição C.S. Oliveira, Aníbal Costa, João C. Nunes, Governo dos Açores/SPRHI, S.A., 501-512. (in portuguese).
Filiatrault A., J.T. Sullivan (2014). Performance-based seismic design of non-structural building components: The next frontier of earthquake engineering, J. Earth. Engin. Engin. Vibration. Special Issue on the State-of-the art and Future Challenges of Earthquake Engineering, 13, 1, 17–46, DOI:10.1007/s11803-014-0238-9.
Grünthal G. (Ed.) (1998). European Macroseismic Scale 1998 (EMS-98). European Seismological Commission, sub commission on Engineering Seismology, Working Group Macroseismic Scales. Conseil del’Europe, Cahiers du Conseil de l’Europe, Cahiers du Centre Européen de Géodynamique et de Séismologie, 15, Luxembourg.
Hemeroteca Digital. O Sismo de 1969 na imprensa portuguesa [Online], Available: http://hemerotecadigital.cm lisboa.pt/EFEMERIDES/Sismo1969/Sismo1969.htm [Consulted in April 2019], Hemeroteca Municipal de Lisboa.
ITERATE – Improved Tools for Disaster Risk Mitigation in Algeria, ECHO/SUB/2016/740181/PREV23, http://www.iterate-eu.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/DE3-NonStructural-Elements.pdf.
Neves, F., A. Costa, R. Vicente, C. S. Oliveira, H. Varum (2012). Seismic vulnerability assessment and characterisation of the buildings on Faial Island, Azores, Bull. Earthq. Engin., 10, 1, 27–44, DOI 10.1007/s10518-011-9276-0.
Neves, F., C.S. Oliveira, A. Costa (2008). Base de dados relativa ao parque habitacional da ilha do Faial e Pico, danos sofridos no sismo de 1998 e processo da reconstrução. “Sismo 1998 - Açores. Uma década depois”, C. Sousa Oliveira, Aníbal Costa, João C. Nunes (eds.), ISBN 978-989-20-1223-0. (41) 515-520.
O Século Ilustrado (1969). Retrieved from http://hemerotecadigital.cm-lisboa.pt/EFEMERIDES/Sismo1969/Sismo1969.htm
Oliveira C.S. (1982). The role of historical seismicity in the evaluation of seismic risk of Lisbon, Proceedings 7th European Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Athens.
Oliveira, C.S., M. A. Ferreira (2008). Impacto do sismo de 1998 no território dos Açores. Principais consequências e indicadores. Sismo 1998 - Açores. Uma década depois. Edição C. S. Oliveira, Aníbal Costa, João C. Nunes, Governo dos Açores/SPRHI, S.A., 717-726.
Solarino, S., M.A. Ferreira, G. Musacchio, R. Rupakhety, H. O’Neill, S. Falsaperla, M. Vicente, M. Lopes, C.S. Oliveira (2021). What scientific information on non-structural elements seismic risk do people need to know? Part 2 - tools for risk communication, Ann. Geophys., 64, (this issue).
Thorvaldsdóttir, S., B. Bessason (2018). Identification of the most vulnerable non-structural components in the pilot study area (Iceland case). KnowRISK project deliverable C2, available at https://knowriskproject.com/project reports/
Thorvaldsdóttir S, Bessason B, Rupakhety R (2021) Towards DRM for residential buildings, Ann. Geophys., 64, (this issue).
Torrisi, A. (2018). Esiti di Agibilità e Danno nell’Emergenza Sismica (schede AeDES) in occasione dei terremoti etnei del 2002 e 2008, Regione Siciliana, Dipartimento della Protezione Civile, Servizio Rischio Sismico e Vulcanico S.03, Nicolosi (Italy).
50 anos do sismo de 28 de Fevereiro de 1969 online, c2019-2020. http://sismo1969.ipma.pt/ [accessed in January 2020]
Type
article
File(s)![]()
![]()
Name
8412-Article Text-26823-1-10-20210723.pdf
Description
appendix
Size
274.47 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
33710fb58fdc0b792e39a87293aa61a2
Name
8412-Article Text-26822-1-10-20210723.pdf
Description
Open Access published article
Size
5.7 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
afdbec70322c22b7bffcdbd4988a1cf5
