Comment on "Evidence of Potential Thermospheric Overcooling During the May 2024 Geomagnetic Superstorm" by Kumar Ranjan et al
Journal
JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH. SPACE PHYSICS
ISSN
2169-9380
2169-9402
Date Issued
2025-04-29
DOI
10.1029/2025JA033891
Abstract
The post-storm neutral density ρ decrease (when it takes place) cannot be prescribed to a decrease in neutral temperature because this contradicts the observed negative foF 2 deviations normally observed during the recovery storm phase. Neutral temperature decrease also contradicts empirical (based on observations) thermospheric models such as MSISE00. The post-storm neutral density decrease is due to a decrease in the atomic oxygen abundance during the recovery storm phase. The increase in atomic oxygen along with elevated storm-time neutral temperature prevents the post-storm neutral density decrease in winter. The observed rarity of the post-storm ρ decrease is due to the interplay between the storm-time decrease in atomic oxygen abundance and the increase in neutral temperature. The two processes work simultaneously in opposite directions during magnetic storms, compensating each other to a great extent. Therefore, the post-storm neutral density decrease is not related to the NO overcooling but can be explained in the framework of the F 2-layer storm mechanism.
