COMMON BEST PRACTICE PROCEDURES FOR SITE-EFFECTS CHARACTERIZATION: RESULTS FROM AN INTERNATIONAL QUESTIONNAIRE
Author(s)
Type
Conference paper
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
5T. Sismologia, geofisica e geologia per l'ingegneria sismica
Editor(s)
Status
Published
Date Issued
September 2018
Conference Location
La Valletta - Malta
Alternative Location
Book of Abstracts of the 36th General Assembly of the European Seismological Commission Sebastiano D'Amico, Pauline Galea, George Bozionelos, Emanuele Colica, Daniela Farrugia and Matthew R. Agius (Eds.)., ESC2018-S34-771
Subjects
Abstract
Setting-up standard practices, together with a
clear evaluation of their quality, are becoming
very important to reach high-level sitecharacterization
metadata, useful for site effects
studies, seismic microzonation, seismic hazard
assessment and many other research fields. In the
last years, several efforts have been done at
national and international level to define
standards and guidelines for seismic site
characterization (e.g., Foti et al., Bull Earthquake
Eng, 2017, doi:10.1007/s10518-017-0206-7;
Geological Survey of Canada, Open File 7078,
2012, doi:10.4095/291753; Consortium of
Organizations for Strong Motion Observation
Systems, http://www.cosmos-eq.org; WP12-
Deliverable D23.12, SESAME European research
project, 2004). Within the 2017-2020 activities of
the “Networking databases of site and station
characterization” (WP7-NA5 of the SERA
“Seismology and Earthquake Engineering
Research Infrastructure Alliance for Europe”
Horizon 2020 Project), European teams are
working on the best practice for site
characterization and related quality assessment
target to network operators and seismological and
engineering communities. More specifically, the
goals of this task are: (i) to evaluate the most
relevant site effects indicators; (ii) to write
practical guidelines for site effects
characterization and related site condition
parameters at rock sites (including topography
effects) and soft soils (including non-linear and
basin effects); (iii) to propose a quality metrics on
the site characterization parameters. As a first
step, we have prepared a Questionnaire for
collecting existing bibliography and best practice
schemes to compute indicators for site effects
characterization. We sent the Questionnaire to
selected research groups of different countries,
both partners of the SERA project (ISTERRE-CNRS,
France; ETH, Switzerland; INGV, Italy; AUTH,
Greece) and several external groups involved in
site characterization (Caltech-USGS, USA; AFAD,
Turkey; Virginia Tech USA; GFZ, Germany; ITSAK,
Greece; University of Potsdam, Germany; UoTUniversity
of Texas, USA; INGV, Italy), and
collected back the answers. Each team provided
the list of site effects indicators, their importance
for site effects assessment (based on expert
judgment) and their preferred methods of analysis
for retrieving the indicators. In the Questionnaire,
the site-effect indicators were grouped into (i)
Scalar (e.g. resonance frequency), (ii) Depthdependent
(e.g. shear-wave Vs profile), (iii)
Frequency-dependent (e.g. spectral ratio), (iv)
Geological/Morphological (e.g. Surface
geology/lithology unit) and (v) Advanced siteeffects
(e.g. numerical 2D or 3D modeling)
parameters. Each indicator is described through
several fields, summarized into five main subsets:
Importance - in-depth index related to the amount
of knowledge on site-effects characterization
supplied by each indicator, and it can assume
three values (basic, intermediate and top),
depending on the expert judgment; Feasibility -
level of difficulty to measure the target indicator
(easy, average and difficult); Data - type of data
used to measure the proposed indicator; Analysis
- method of analysis and suggested code to derive
the indicator, including the value’s selection and
uncertainty estimation; Bibliography - references
and guidelines related to the best practice of
measurement and analysis. A preliminary analysis
of the Questionnaires reveals a consensus on
several basic indicators, such as the resonance
frequency, Vs30 or the 1D Vs profile, even if the
teams use different data acquisition, analysis
methods and metrics. Fewer teams indicated
more advanced parameters, such as 2D-3D site
goals of this task are: (i) to evaluate the most
relevant site effects indicators; (ii) to write
practical guidelines for site effects
characterization and related site condition
parameters at rock sites (including topography
effects) and soft soils (including non-linear and
basin effects); (iii) to propose a quality metrics on
the site characterization parameters. As a first
step, we have prepared a Questionnaire for
collecting existing bibliography and best practice
schemes to compute indicators for site effects
characterization. We sent the Questionnaire to
selected research groups of different countries,
both partners of the SERA project (ISTERRE-CNRS,
France; ETH, Switzerland; INGV, Italy; AUTH,
Greece) and several external groups involved in
site characterization (Caltech-USGS, USA; AFAD,
Turkey; Virginia Tech USA; GFZ, Germany; ITSAK,
Greece; University of Potsdam, Germany; UoTUniversity
of Texas, USA; INGV, Italy), and
collected back the answers. Each team provided
the list of site effects indicators, their importance
for site effects assessment (based on expert
judgment) and their preferred methods of analysis
for retrieving the indicators. In the Questionnaire,
the site-effect indicators were grouped into (i)
Scalar (e.g. resonance frequency), (ii) Depthdependent
(e.g. shear-wave Vs profile), (iii)
Frequency-dependent (e.g. spectral ratio), (iv)
Geological/Morphological (e.g. Surface
geology/lithology unit) and (v) Advanced siteeffects
(e.g. numerical 2D or 3D modeling)
parameters. Each indicator is described through
several fields, summarized into five main subsets:
Importance - in-depth index related to the amount
of knowledge on site-effects characterization
supplied by each indicator, and it can assume
three values (basic, intermediate and top),
depending on the expert judgment; Feasibility -
level of difficulty to measure the target indicator
(easy, average and difficult); Data - type of data
used to measure the proposed indicator; Analysis
- method of analysis and suggested code to derive
the indicator, including the value’s selection and
uncertainty estimation; Bibliography - references
and guidelines related to the best practice of
measurement and analysis. A preliminary analysis
of the Questionnaires reveals a consensus on
several basic indicators, such as the resonance
frequency, Vs30 or the 1D Vs profile, even if the
teams use different data acquisition, analysis
methods and metrics. Fewer teams indicated
more advanced parameters, such as 2D-3D site
clear evaluation of their quality, are becoming
very important to reach high-level sitecharacterization
metadata, useful for site effects
studies, seismic microzonation, seismic hazard
assessment and many other research fields. In the
last years, several efforts have been done at
national and international level to define
standards and guidelines for seismic site
characterization (e.g., Foti et al., Bull Earthquake
Eng, 2017, doi:10.1007/s10518-017-0206-7;
Geological Survey of Canada, Open File 7078,
2012, doi:10.4095/291753; Consortium of
Organizations for Strong Motion Observation
Systems, http://www.cosmos-eq.org; WP12-
Deliverable D23.12, SESAME European research
project, 2004). Within the 2017-2020 activities of
the “Networking databases of site and station
characterization” (WP7-NA5 of the SERA
“Seismology and Earthquake Engineering
Research Infrastructure Alliance for Europe”
Horizon 2020 Project), European teams are
working on the best practice for site
characterization and related quality assessment
target to network operators and seismological and
engineering communities. More specifically, the
goals of this task are: (i) to evaluate the most
relevant site effects indicators; (ii) to write
practical guidelines for site effects
characterization and related site condition
parameters at rock sites (including topography
effects) and soft soils (including non-linear and
basin effects); (iii) to propose a quality metrics on
the site characterization parameters. As a first
step, we have prepared a Questionnaire for
collecting existing bibliography and best practice
schemes to compute indicators for site effects
characterization. We sent the Questionnaire to
selected research groups of different countries,
both partners of the SERA project (ISTERRE-CNRS,
France; ETH, Switzerland; INGV, Italy; AUTH,
Greece) and several external groups involved in
site characterization (Caltech-USGS, USA; AFAD,
Turkey; Virginia Tech USA; GFZ, Germany; ITSAK,
Greece; University of Potsdam, Germany; UoTUniversity
of Texas, USA; INGV, Italy), and
collected back the answers. Each team provided
the list of site effects indicators, their importance
for site effects assessment (based on expert
judgment) and their preferred methods of analysis
for retrieving the indicators. In the Questionnaire,
the site-effect indicators were grouped into (i)
Scalar (e.g. resonance frequency), (ii) Depthdependent
(e.g. shear-wave Vs profile), (iii)
Frequency-dependent (e.g. spectral ratio), (iv)
Geological/Morphological (e.g. Surface
geology/lithology unit) and (v) Advanced siteeffects
(e.g. numerical 2D or 3D modeling)
parameters. Each indicator is described through
several fields, summarized into five main subsets:
Importance - in-depth index related to the amount
of knowledge on site-effects characterization
supplied by each indicator, and it can assume
three values (basic, intermediate and top),
depending on the expert judgment; Feasibility -
level of difficulty to measure the target indicator
(easy, average and difficult); Data - type of data
used to measure the proposed indicator; Analysis
- method of analysis and suggested code to derive
the indicator, including the value’s selection and
uncertainty estimation; Bibliography - references
and guidelines related to the best practice of
measurement and analysis. A preliminary analysis
of the Questionnaires reveals a consensus on
several basic indicators, such as the resonance
frequency, Vs30 or the 1D Vs profile, even if the
teams use different data acquisition, analysis
methods and metrics. Fewer teams indicated
more advanced parameters, such as 2D-3D site
goals of this task are: (i) to evaluate the most
relevant site effects indicators; (ii) to write
practical guidelines for site effects
characterization and related site condition
parameters at rock sites (including topography
effects) and soft soils (including non-linear and
basin effects); (iii) to propose a quality metrics on
the site characterization parameters. As a first
step, we have prepared a Questionnaire for
collecting existing bibliography and best practice
schemes to compute indicators for site effects
characterization. We sent the Questionnaire to
selected research groups of different countries,
both partners of the SERA project (ISTERRE-CNRS,
France; ETH, Switzerland; INGV, Italy; AUTH,
Greece) and several external groups involved in
site characterization (Caltech-USGS, USA; AFAD,
Turkey; Virginia Tech USA; GFZ, Germany; ITSAK,
Greece; University of Potsdam, Germany; UoTUniversity
of Texas, USA; INGV, Italy), and
collected back the answers. Each team provided
the list of site effects indicators, their importance
for site effects assessment (based on expert
judgment) and their preferred methods of analysis
for retrieving the indicators. In the Questionnaire,
the site-effect indicators were grouped into (i)
Scalar (e.g. resonance frequency), (ii) Depthdependent
(e.g. shear-wave Vs profile), (iii)
Frequency-dependent (e.g. spectral ratio), (iv)
Geological/Morphological (e.g. Surface
geology/lithology unit) and (v) Advanced siteeffects
(e.g. numerical 2D or 3D modeling)
parameters. Each indicator is described through
several fields, summarized into five main subsets:
Importance - in-depth index related to the amount
of knowledge on site-effects characterization
supplied by each indicator, and it can assume
three values (basic, intermediate and top),
depending on the expert judgment; Feasibility -
level of difficulty to measure the target indicator
(easy, average and difficult); Data - type of data
used to measure the proposed indicator; Analysis
- method of analysis and suggested code to derive
the indicator, including the value’s selection and
uncertainty estimation; Bibliography - references
and guidelines related to the best practice of
measurement and analysis. A preliminary analysis
of the Questionnaires reveals a consensus on
several basic indicators, such as the resonance
frequency, Vs30 or the 1D Vs profile, even if the
teams use different data acquisition, analysis
methods and metrics. Fewer teams indicated
more advanced parameters, such as 2D-3D site
File(s)![]()
Name
ESC2018_Cultrera_S34-771.pdf
Description
conference material
Size
57.17 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
97051bb97bd5a924e5d33b315119fa70
