A Microtremor Survey in the Area Shocked by the ML 5.2 Salò Earthquake (North Italy): An Empirical Approach to Determine the Effects of Ground Motions
Author(s)
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
1.1. TTC - Monitoraggio sismico del territorio nazionale
3.1. Fisica dei terremoti
Status
Published
JCR Journal
JCR Journal
Peer review journal
Yes
Issue/vol(year)
/13 (2009)
Pages (printed)
1029-1046
Date Issued
October 1, 2009
Subjects
Abstract
In this work, the results of a quick microtremor survey performed in the municipalities situated in
the epicentre area of the Ml 5.2 2004 Salo` earthquake (North Italy) are presented. The aim of this
study is to understand if the large amount of damage caused by the event (about 215 million euros
only in the areas near to the epicenter) is correlated more to the local surface geology conditions or
to the vulnerability of ancient Italian historical centers.
A preliminary seismic zonation was carried out in 5 villages including about 30 measurements
of microtremors analyzed by the Nakamura technique (hereinafter HVNR). The points of measurement
were carefully selected considering sites located both near damaged buildings and over
different local geology conditions (alluvium deposits, fluvial-glacial deposits, debris fans and
rock). In order to strengthen the HVNR results and to evaluate the reliability of the Nakamura
analysis, a comparison with spectral ratios calculated on earthquakes (hereinafter HVSR) recorded
at the strong motion station of Vobarno was made. In general, the outcomes of the survey highlight
a possible correlation between local geology conditions and ground motion amplification for
different frequency bands. In order to check if this evidence is linked with the damage, a series
of macroseismic intensity values were collected for different zones of the investigated area, and a
nonparametric correlation approach was used to establish a possible correlation between damage
and ground motion amplification for selected frequency bands. The results show, from a statistical
point of view, that in the area surrounding the epicenter of the November 24, 2004 mainshock, the
damage pattern is not strongly dependent upon the local surface geology but more correlated to the
low quality of the civil structures present in the area, including old buildings of the last century.
the epicentre area of the Ml 5.2 2004 Salo` earthquake (North Italy) are presented. The aim of this
study is to understand if the large amount of damage caused by the event (about 215 million euros
only in the areas near to the epicenter) is correlated more to the local surface geology conditions or
to the vulnerability of ancient Italian historical centers.
A preliminary seismic zonation was carried out in 5 villages including about 30 measurements
of microtremors analyzed by the Nakamura technique (hereinafter HVNR). The points of measurement
were carefully selected considering sites located both near damaged buildings and over
different local geology conditions (alluvium deposits, fluvial-glacial deposits, debris fans and
rock). In order to strengthen the HVNR results and to evaluate the reliability of the Nakamura
analysis, a comparison with spectral ratios calculated on earthquakes (hereinafter HVSR) recorded
at the strong motion station of Vobarno was made. In general, the outcomes of the survey highlight
a possible correlation between local geology conditions and ground motion amplification for
different frequency bands. In order to check if this evidence is linked with the damage, a series
of macroseismic intensity values were collected for different zones of the investigated area, and a
nonparametric correlation approach was used to establish a possible correlation between damage
and ground motion amplification for selected frequency bands. The results show, from a statistical
point of view, that in the area surrounding the epicenter of the November 24, 2004 mainshock, the
damage pattern is not strongly dependent upon the local surface geology but more correlated to the
low quality of the civil structures present in the area, including old buildings of the last century.
References
Augliera, P., D’Alema, E., Marzorati, S., Massa, M., De Gori, P., and Marchetti, A. [2006]. Data
set Garda 2004: elaborazione dati, installazione stazioni sismiche (2004 Garda dataset: data
processing, installation of seismic stations), Convenzione ProCiv-INGV 2004–2006 - Progetto
DPC-S3: scenari di scuotimento in aree di interesse prioritario e/o strategico, DPC-S3:
Deliverable12, DVD (in Italian).
Bard, P. Y. [1999]. ‘‘Microtremor measurement: a tool for site effect estimations?’’, Proc. of the
2nd International Symposium on the Effects of the Surface Geology on Seismic Motion, ESG98,
Yokohama, Japan, pp. 1251–1279.
Boni, A, and Cassinis, G. [1972]. ‘‘Carta geologica delle Prealpi Bresciane a Sud dell’Adamello
1:50000,’’ Atti 1st. Geol. Univ. Pavia, 23.
CNR-IRRS, and Regione Lombardia – Servizio Geologico [1996]. ‘‘Determinazione del rischio
sismico a fini urbanistici in Lombardia,’’ 148 p (in Italian).
A Microtremor Survey in Val Sabbia Valley (North Italy) 1045
Downloaded By: [Ist Naz Geofisica E Vulcan] At: 09:00 1 October 2009
Faccioli, E. and Paolucci, R. [2005]. ‘‘Elementi di sismologia applicati all’ingegneria,’’ 268 pp,
Pitagora Ed., Bologna (in Italian).
Field, E. H. and Jacob, K. H. [1995]. ‘‘A comparison and test of various site-response estimation
techniques, including three that are non reference-site dependent,’’ Bulletin of the Seismological
Society of America 85, 1127–1143.
Franceschina, G., Pessina, V., Di Giacomo, D., Massa, M., Castellano, S., Mulargia, F., and
Mucciarelli, M. [2008]. ‘‘Ricostruzione del moto del suolo per il terremoto del Garda del
2004,’’ Memorie della Societa` Geologica Italiana 128, 217–228.
Gallipoli, M. R., Mucciarelli M., Gallicchio S., Tropeano M., and Lizza, C. [2004]. ‘‘Horizontal to
vertical spectra ratio (HVSR) measurements in the area damaged by the 2002 Molise, Italy,
earthquake,’’ Earthquake Spectra 20(S1), 81–93.
Gruppo di lavoro [2004]. Redazione della mappa di pericolosita` sismica prevista dall’ordinanza
PCM 3274 del 20 Marzo 2003, Rapporto conclusivo per il Dipartimento della Protezione Civile,
INGV, Milano - Roma, 65 (in Italian).
Gruppo di lavoro CPTI [2004]. ‘‘Catalogo Parametrico dei Terremoti Italian,’’ versione 2004
(CPTI04), INGV, Bologna (url: http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI04/).
Konno, K. and Ohmachi, T. [1998]. ‘‘Ground-motion characteristic estimated from spectral ratio
between horizontal and vertical components of microtremors,’’ Bulletin of the Seismological
Society of America 88, 228–241.
Lachet, C. and Bard, P. Y. [1994]. ‘‘Numerical and theoretical investigations on the possibilities
and limitations of the Nakamura’s technique,’’ Journal of Physical Earth 42, 377–397.
Mucciarelli, M. [1998]. ‘‘Reliability and applicability of Nakamura’s technique using microtremors
on the ground surface: an experimental approach,’’ Journal of Earthquake Engineering 2,
625–638.
Mucciarelli, M. and Monachesi, G. [1998]. ‘‘A quick survey of local amplifications and their
correlation with damage observed during the Umbro-Marchesan (Italy) earthquake of
September 26, 1997,’’ Journal of Earthquake Engineering 2, 325–337.
Mucciarelli, M. and Monachesi, G. [1999]. ‘‘The Bovec (Slovenia) earthquake, April 1998:
preliminary quantitative association among damage, ground motion amplification and building
frequencies,’’ Journal of Earthquake Engineering 3, 317–327.
Mucciarelli, M. and Gallipoli, M. R. [2001]. ‘‘A critical review of 10 years of microtremor HVSR
technique,’’ Boll. Geof. Teor. Appl. 42, 255–266.
Nakamura, Y. [1989]. ‘‘A method for dynamic characteristics estimations of subsurface using
microtremors on the ground surface,’’ Quarterly Report RTRI Japan 30, 25–33.
Nakamura, Y. [2000]. ‘‘Clear identification of fundamental of Nakamura’s technique and its
applications, #2656,’’ 12th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, New Zealand.
Parolai, S., Bormann, P., and Milkereit, C. [2001]. ‘‘Assessment of the natural frequency of the
sedimentary cover in the Cologne area (Germany) using noise measurements,’’ Journal of
Earthquake Engineering 5, 541–564.
Parolai, S., Richwalski, S. M., Milkereit, C., and Bormann, P. [2004]. ‘‘Assessment of the stability
of H/V spectral ratios from ambient noise and comparison with earthquake data in the Cologne
area (Germany),’’ Tectonophysics 390, 57–73.
QUEST (QUick Earthquake Survey Team) [2005]. ‘‘Rilievo macrosismico del terremoto del Garda
del 24 novembre 2004,’’ Ingegneria Sismica, Anno XXII – 2, 44–59 (in Italian).
Regione Lombardia [2002]. ‘‘CD Progetto di Cartografia geoambientale, dati vettoriali, scala
1:10000,’’ Comunita` Montana Val Sabbia (in Italian).
set Garda 2004: elaborazione dati, installazione stazioni sismiche (2004 Garda dataset: data
processing, installation of seismic stations), Convenzione ProCiv-INGV 2004–2006 - Progetto
DPC-S3: scenari di scuotimento in aree di interesse prioritario e/o strategico, DPC-S3:
Deliverable12, DVD (in Italian).
Bard, P. Y. [1999]. ‘‘Microtremor measurement: a tool for site effect estimations?’’, Proc. of the
2nd International Symposium on the Effects of the Surface Geology on Seismic Motion, ESG98,
Yokohama, Japan, pp. 1251–1279.
Boni, A, and Cassinis, G. [1972]. ‘‘Carta geologica delle Prealpi Bresciane a Sud dell’Adamello
1:50000,’’ Atti 1st. Geol. Univ. Pavia, 23.
CNR-IRRS, and Regione Lombardia – Servizio Geologico [1996]. ‘‘Determinazione del rischio
sismico a fini urbanistici in Lombardia,’’ 148 p (in Italian).
A Microtremor Survey in Val Sabbia Valley (North Italy) 1045
Downloaded By: [Ist Naz Geofisica E Vulcan] At: 09:00 1 October 2009
Faccioli, E. and Paolucci, R. [2005]. ‘‘Elementi di sismologia applicati all’ingegneria,’’ 268 pp,
Pitagora Ed., Bologna (in Italian).
Field, E. H. and Jacob, K. H. [1995]. ‘‘A comparison and test of various site-response estimation
techniques, including three that are non reference-site dependent,’’ Bulletin of the Seismological
Society of America 85, 1127–1143.
Franceschina, G., Pessina, V., Di Giacomo, D., Massa, M., Castellano, S., Mulargia, F., and
Mucciarelli, M. [2008]. ‘‘Ricostruzione del moto del suolo per il terremoto del Garda del
2004,’’ Memorie della Societa` Geologica Italiana 128, 217–228.
Gallipoli, M. R., Mucciarelli M., Gallicchio S., Tropeano M., and Lizza, C. [2004]. ‘‘Horizontal to
vertical spectra ratio (HVSR) measurements in the area damaged by the 2002 Molise, Italy,
earthquake,’’ Earthquake Spectra 20(S1), 81–93.
Gruppo di lavoro [2004]. Redazione della mappa di pericolosita` sismica prevista dall’ordinanza
PCM 3274 del 20 Marzo 2003, Rapporto conclusivo per il Dipartimento della Protezione Civile,
INGV, Milano - Roma, 65 (in Italian).
Gruppo di lavoro CPTI [2004]. ‘‘Catalogo Parametrico dei Terremoti Italian,’’ versione 2004
(CPTI04), INGV, Bologna (url: http://emidius.mi.ingv.it/CPTI04/).
Konno, K. and Ohmachi, T. [1998]. ‘‘Ground-motion characteristic estimated from spectral ratio
between horizontal and vertical components of microtremors,’’ Bulletin of the Seismological
Society of America 88, 228–241.
Lachet, C. and Bard, P. Y. [1994]. ‘‘Numerical and theoretical investigations on the possibilities
and limitations of the Nakamura’s technique,’’ Journal of Physical Earth 42, 377–397.
Mucciarelli, M. [1998]. ‘‘Reliability and applicability of Nakamura’s technique using microtremors
on the ground surface: an experimental approach,’’ Journal of Earthquake Engineering 2,
625–638.
Mucciarelli, M. and Monachesi, G. [1998]. ‘‘A quick survey of local amplifications and their
correlation with damage observed during the Umbro-Marchesan (Italy) earthquake of
September 26, 1997,’’ Journal of Earthquake Engineering 2, 325–337.
Mucciarelli, M. and Monachesi, G. [1999]. ‘‘The Bovec (Slovenia) earthquake, April 1998:
preliminary quantitative association among damage, ground motion amplification and building
frequencies,’’ Journal of Earthquake Engineering 3, 317–327.
Mucciarelli, M. and Gallipoli, M. R. [2001]. ‘‘A critical review of 10 years of microtremor HVSR
technique,’’ Boll. Geof. Teor. Appl. 42, 255–266.
Nakamura, Y. [1989]. ‘‘A method for dynamic characteristics estimations of subsurface using
microtremors on the ground surface,’’ Quarterly Report RTRI Japan 30, 25–33.
Nakamura, Y. [2000]. ‘‘Clear identification of fundamental of Nakamura’s technique and its
applications, #2656,’’ 12th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, New Zealand.
Parolai, S., Bormann, P., and Milkereit, C. [2001]. ‘‘Assessment of the natural frequency of the
sedimentary cover in the Cologne area (Germany) using noise measurements,’’ Journal of
Earthquake Engineering 5, 541–564.
Parolai, S., Richwalski, S. M., Milkereit, C., and Bormann, P. [2004]. ‘‘Assessment of the stability
of H/V spectral ratios from ambient noise and comparison with earthquake data in the Cologne
area (Germany),’’ Tectonophysics 390, 57–73.
QUEST (QUick Earthquake Survey Team) [2005]. ‘‘Rilievo macrosismico del terremoto del Garda
del 24 novembre 2004,’’ Ingegneria Sismica, Anno XXII – 2, 44–59 (in Italian).
Regione Lombardia [2002]. ‘‘CD Progetto di Cartografia geoambientale, dati vettoriali, scala
1:10000,’’ Comunita` Montana Val Sabbia (in Italian).
Type
article
File(s)![]()
Name
Massa_et_al_JEE_Val_Sabbia.pdf
Size
1.19 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
378061a348b246b7ce78314aec593115
