Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
http://hdl.handle.net/2122/9266
Authors: | Cocco, M.* Cultrera, G.* Amato, A.* Braun, T.* Cerase, A.* Margheriti, L.* Bonaccorso, A.* Demartin, M..* De Martini, P. M.* Galadini, F.* Meletti, C.* Nostro, C.* Pacor, F.* Pantosti, D.* Pondrelli, S.* Quareni, F.* Todesco, M.* |
Title: | The L'Aquila trial | Journal: | Geoethics: The Role and Responsibility of Geoscientists | Series/Report no.: | Special Publications, 419/(2015) | Publisher: | Geological Society, London | Issue Date: | 2015 | DOI: | 10.1144/SP419.13 | Keywords: | L’Aquila earthquake trial risk communication incertitude criminal responsibility |
Subject Classification: | 05. General::05.09. Miscellaneous::05.09.99. General or miscellaneous | Abstract: | The first stage of the trial in L’Aquila (Italy) ended with a conviction of seven experts, convened by the head of Civil Protection on 31 March 2009, for multiple manslaughter and serious injuries. They were sentenced to six years in jail, perpetual interdiction from public office and a fine of several million euros to be paid to the victims of the earthquake of 6 April 2009 (moment magnitude 6.3) for having caused, by their negligent conduct, the death of 29 persons and the injury of several others. The verdict had a tremendous impact on the scientific community and on the way scientists deliver their expert opinions to decision makers and society. This paper analyses the scientific argumentations reported in the Verdict Motivations, where scientific data and results were largely debated and misused to demonstrate that they should have been considered a tool to predict an impending large earthquake. Moreover, we show that the supposed message of reassurance was not generated at the experts’ meeting or by the official Istituto Nazionale di Geofisica e Vulcanologia reports. The media had a key role in conveying information during the seismic swarm, contributing to the risk perception. We stress that prevention actions based on seismic hazard knowledge are the best defence against earthquakes. |
Appears in Collections: | Article published / in press |
Files in This Item:
File | Description | Size | Format | Existing users please Login |
---|---|---|---|---|
Cocco_et_al-Geothics.pdf | 8.12 MB | Adobe PDF |
Page view(s) 5
1,641
checked on Apr 17, 2024
Download(s) 50
82
checked on Apr 17, 2024