Disentangling ionospheric refraction and diffraction effects in GNSS raw phase through fast iterative filtering technique
Author(s)
Language
English
Obiettivo Specifico
2TM. Divulgazione Scientifica
Status
Published
JCR Journal
JCR Journal
Peer review journal
Yes
Journal
Issue/vol(year)
/24(2020)
ISSN
1080-5370
Electronic ISSN
1521-1886
Publisher
Springer
Pages (printed)
id 85
Date Issued
June 29, 2020
Last version
https://rdcu.be/b5jck
Subjects
Disentangling ionospheric refraction and diffraction effects in GNSS raw phase through fast iterative filtering technique
Subjects
Abstract
We contribute to the debate on the identification of phase scintillation induced by the ionosphere on the Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) by introducing a phase detrending method able to provide realistic values of the phase scintillation index at high latitude. It is based on the Fast Iterative Filtering (FIF) signal decomposition technique, which is a recently developed fast implementation of the well-established Adaptive Local Iterative Filtering (ALIF) algorithm. FIF has been conceived to decompose nonstationary signals efficiently and providing a discrete set of oscillating functions, each of them having its frequency. It overcomes most of the problems that arise when using traditional time-frequency analysis techniques and relies on a consolidated mathematical basis since its a priori convergence and stability have been proved. By relying on the capability of FIF to efficiently identify the frequencies embedded in the GNSS raw phase, we define a method based on the FIF-derived spectral features to identify the proper cutoff frequency for phase detrending. To test such a method, we analyze the data acquired from GPS and Galileo signals over Antarctica during the September 2017 storm by the Ionospheric Scintillation Monitor Receiver (ISMR) located in Concordia Station (75.10°S, 123.33°E). Different cases of diffraction and refraction effects are provided, showing the capability of the method in deriving a more accurate determination of the SigmaPhi index. We found values of cutoff frequency in the range of 0.73 to 0.83 Hz, providing further evidence of the inadequacy of the choice of 0.1 Hz, which is often used when dealing with ionospheric scintillation monitoring at high latitudes.
Sponsors
This research is supported by TREASURE, a project funded by the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions grant agreement n.722023 (http://ww.treasure-gnss.eu).
References
Alfonsi L, Cilliers PJ, Romano V, Hunstad I, Correia E, Linty N, Riley
P (2016) First observations of GNSS ionospheric scintillations
from DemoGRAPE project. Space Weather 14(10):704–709
Aquino M, Moore T, Dodson A, Waugh S, Souter J, Rodrigues FS
(2005) Implications of ionospheric scintillation for GNSS users
in Northern Europe. J Navig 58(2):241–256
Basu S, Groves KM, Basu S, Sultan PJ (2002) Specification and
forecasting of scintillations in communication/navigation
links: current status and future plans. J Atmos Solar Terr Phys
64(16):1745–1754
Beach TL (2006) Perils of the GPS phase scintillation index (φ). Radio
Sci 41(5):1–7
Bertello I, Piersanti M, Candidi M, Diego P, Ubertini P (2018) Electromagnetic
field observations by the DEMETER satellite in
connection with the 2009 L’Aquila earthquake. Ann Geophys
36(5):1483–1493
Bougard B, Sleewaegen J-M, Spogli L, Veettil SV, Monico JF (2011)
CIGALA: challenging the solar maximum in brazil with PolaRxS.
In: Proceedings of the. ION GNSS 2011, Institute of Navigation,
Portland, OR, September 20–23, pp 2572–2579
Carrano CS, Rino CL (2016) A theory of scintillation for two-component
power law irregularity spectra: overview and numerical
results. Radio Sci 51(6):789–813
Carrano CS, Groves KM, McNeil WJ, Doherty PH (2013) Direct
measurement of the residual in the ionosphere-free linear combination
during scintillation. In: Proceedings of the ION NTM
2013, Institute of Navigation, San Diego, CA, January 27–29,
pp 585–596
Cicone A (2019) Nonstationary signal decomposition for dummies.
In: Advances in mathematical methods and high performance
computing, Springer, Cham, 2019, pp 69–82
Cicone A (2020) Iterative filtering as a direct method for the decomposition
of nonstationary signals. Numer Algorith 2020:1–17
Cicone A, Dell’Acqua P (2019) Study of boundary conditions in the
iterative filtering method for the decomposition of nonstationary
signals. J Comput Appl Math 2020(373):112248
Cicone A, Zhou H (2020) Iterative filtering algorithm numerical
analysis with new efficient implementations based on FFT. Submitted.
ArXiv: 1802.01359
Cicone A, Liu J, Zhou H (2016) Adaptive local iterative filtering
for signal decomposition and instantaneous frequency analysis.
Appl Comput Harm Anal 41(2):384–411
Conker RS, El-Arini MB, Hegarty CJ, Hsiao T (2003) Modeling
the effects of ionospheric scintillation on GPS/Satellite-Based
Augmentation System availability. Radio Sci 38(1):1–1
De Franceschi G, Spogli L, Alfonsi L, Romano V, Cesaroni C, Hunstad
I (2019) The ionospheric irregularities climatology over
Svalbard from solar cycle 23. Sci Rep 9(1):1–14
Forte B (2005) Optimum detrending of raw GPS data for scintillation
measurements at auroral latitudes. J Atmos Solar Terr Phys
67(12):1100–1109
Forte B, Radicella SM (2002) Problems in data treatment for ionospheric
scintillation measurements. Radio Sci 37(6):1–8
Forte B, Radicella SM (2004) Geometrical control of scintillation
indices: what happens for GPS satellites. Radio Sci 39(5):1–13
Fremouw EJ, Leadabrand RL, Livingston RC, Cousins MD, Rino
CL, Fair BC, Long RA (1978) Early results from the DNA
Wideband satellite experiment—Complex-signal scintillation.
Radio Sci 13(1):167–187
Ghafoori F, Skone S (2015) Impact of equatorial ionospheric irregularities
on GNSS receivers using real and synthetic scintillation
signals. Radio Sci 50(4):294–317
Gherm VE, Zernov NN, Strangeways HJ (2011) Effects of diffraction
by ionospheric electron density irregularities on the range error
in GNSS dual-frequency positioning and phase decorrelation.
Radio Sci 46(3):1–10
Ghobadi H, Testa P, Spogli L, Cafaro M, Alfonsi L, Romano V,
Bru R (2019) User-oriented ICT cloud architecture for highaccuracy
GNSS-based services. Sensors 19(11):2635
Huang NE, Wu Z, Long SR, Arnold KC, Chen X, Blank K (2009)
On instantaneous frequency. Adv Adap Data Anal 1(2):177–229
Keskinen MJ, Ossakow SL (1983) Theories of high-latitude ionospheric
irregularities: a review. Radio Sci 18(6):1077–1091
Lin L, Wang Y, Zhou H (2009) Iterative filtering as an alternative
algorithm for empirical mode decomposition. Adv Adap Data
Anal 1(4):543–560
Linty N, Minetto A, Dovis F, Spogli L (2018) Effects of phase scintillation
on the GNSS positioning error during the September
2017 storm at Svalbard. Space Weather 16(9):1317–1329
Materassi M, Mitchell CN (2007) Wavelet analysis of GPS amplitude
scintillation: a case study. Radio Sci 42(1):1–10
Materassi M, Piersanti M, Consolini G, Diego P, D’Angelo G, Bertello
I, Cicone A (2019) Stepping into the equatorward boundary
of the auroral oval: preliminary results of multi scale statistical
analysis. Ann Geophys 62(4):455
McCaffrey AM, Jayachandran PT (2019) Determination of the refractive
contribution to GPS phase “Scintillation”. J Geophys Res
Space Phys 124(2):1454–1469
Moen J, Oksavik K, Alfonsi L, Daabakk Y, Romano V, Spogli L (2013)
Space weather challenges of the polar cap ionosphere. J Space
Weather Space Clim 2013(3):A02
Muella MT, de Paula ER, Jonah OF (2014) GPS L1-frequency observations
of equatorial scintillations and irregularity zonal velocities.
Surv Geophys 35(2):335–357
Mushini SC, Jayachandran PT, Langley RB, MacDougall JW, Pokhotelov
D (2012) Improved amplitude-and phase-scintillation indices
derived from wavelet detrended high-latitude GPS data. GPS
Sol 16(3):363–373
Najmafshar M, Skone S, Ghafoori F (2014) GNSS data processing
investigations for characterizing ionospheric scintillation. In:
ION GNSS, 2014, Institute of Navigation, Tampa, FL, September
8–12, pp 1190–1202
Niu F, Morton Y, Wang J, Pelgrum W (2012) GPS carrier phase
detrending methods and performances for ionosphere scintillation
studies. In: Proceedings of the ION GNSS, 2012, Institute
of Navigation, Nashville, TN, September 17–21, pp 1462–1467
Park J, Sreeja V, Aquino M, Cesaroni C, Spogli L, Dodson A, De
Franceschi G (2016) Performance of ionospheric maps in support
of long baseline GNSS kinematic positioning at low latitudes.
Radio Sci 51(5):429–442
Piersanti M, Cesaroni C, Spogli L, Alberti T (2017) Does TEC react to
a sudden impulse as a whole? The 2015 Saint Patrick’s Day storm
event. Adv Space Res 60(8):1807–1816
Piersanti M, Materassi M, Cicone A, Spogli L, Zhou H, Ezquer RG
(2018) Adaptive local iterative filtering: a promising technique
for the analysis of nonstationary signals. J Geophys Res Space
Phys 123(1):1031–1046
Rino C (2011) The theory of scintillation with applications in remote
sensing. Wiley, New York
Romano V, Ghobadi H, Spogli L, Cafaro M, Alfonsi L, Cicone A,
Linty N (2019) Disentangling ionospheric refraction and diffraction
effects in GNSS raw phase through fast iterative filtering
technique. In: AGU fall meeting 2019. AGU
Spogli L, Alfonsi L, Cilliers PJ, Correia E, De Franceschi G, Mitchell
CN, Romano V, Kinrade J, Cabrera MA (2013) GPS scintillations
and total electron content climatology in the southern low, middle
and high latitude regions. Ann Geophys 56(2):0220
GPS Solutions (2020) 24:85
Spogli L, Piersanti M, Cesaroni C, Materassi M, Cicone A, Alfonsi L,
Romano V, Ezquer RG (2019) Role of the external drivers in the
occurrence of low-latitude ionospheric scintillation revealed by
multi-scale analysis. J Space Weather Space Clim 2019(9):A35
Stallone A, Cicone A, Materassi M, Zhou H (2020) New insights and
best practices for the successful use of Empirical Mode Decomposition.
Iterative Filtering and derived algorithms, Submitted
Tinin MV (2015) Eliminating diffraction effects during multi-frequency
correction in global navigation satellite systems. J Geodesy
89(5):491–503
Van Dierendonck AJ, Arbesser-Rastburg B (2004) Measuring Ionospheric
scintillation in the equatorial region over Africa, including
measurements from SBAS geostationary satellite signals. In:
Proceedings of the ION GNSS 2004, Institute of Navigation, Long
Beach, CA, September 21–24, pp 316–324
Van Dierendonck AJ, Klobuchar J, Quyen H (1993) Ionospheric Scintillation
monitoring using commercial single frequency C/A code
receivers. In: Proceedings of the ION GPS 1993, Institute of Navigation,
Salt Lake City, UT, September 22–24, pp 1333–1342
Wang Y, Zhang QH, Jayachandran PT, Moen J, Xing ZY, Chadwick R,
Ma YZ, Ruohoniemi JM, Lester M (2018) Experimental evidence
on the dependence of the standard GPS phase scintillation index
on the ionospheric plasma drift around noon sector of the polar
ionosphere. J Geophys Res Space Phys 123(3):2370–2378
Wernik AW, Secan JA, Fremouw EJ (2003) Ionospheric irregularities
and scintillation. Adv Space Res 31(4):971–981
Wu Z, Huang NE (2009) Ensemble empirical mode decomposition:
a noise-assisted data analysis method. Adv Adap Data Anal
1(1):1–41
Yeh KC, Liu CH (1982) Radio wave scintillations in the ionosphere.
Proc IEEE 70(4):324–360
Yen NC, Tung CC, Liu HH (1998) The empirical mode decomposition
and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and nonstationary time
series analysis. Proc R Soc Lond A 454:903–995
Zhang L, Morton Y, van Graas F, Beach T (2010) Characterization
of GNSS signal parameters under ionosphere scintillation conditions
using software-based tracking algorithms. In: IEEE/ION
position, location and navigation symposium, Indian Wells, CA,
pp 264–275
Zhang K, Li X, Xiong C, Meng X, Li X, Yuan Y, Zhang X (2019) The
Influence of Geomagnetic Storm of 7‐8 September 2017 on the
Swarm Precise Orbit Determination. J Geophys Res Space Phys
124(8):6971–6984
P (2016) First observations of GNSS ionospheric scintillations
from DemoGRAPE project. Space Weather 14(10):704–709
Aquino M, Moore T, Dodson A, Waugh S, Souter J, Rodrigues FS
(2005) Implications of ionospheric scintillation for GNSS users
in Northern Europe. J Navig 58(2):241–256
Basu S, Groves KM, Basu S, Sultan PJ (2002) Specification and
forecasting of scintillations in communication/navigation
links: current status and future plans. J Atmos Solar Terr Phys
64(16):1745–1754
Beach TL (2006) Perils of the GPS phase scintillation index (φ). Radio
Sci 41(5):1–7
Bertello I, Piersanti M, Candidi M, Diego P, Ubertini P (2018) Electromagnetic
field observations by the DEMETER satellite in
connection with the 2009 L’Aquila earthquake. Ann Geophys
36(5):1483–1493
Bougard B, Sleewaegen J-M, Spogli L, Veettil SV, Monico JF (2011)
CIGALA: challenging the solar maximum in brazil with PolaRxS.
In: Proceedings of the. ION GNSS 2011, Institute of Navigation,
Portland, OR, September 20–23, pp 2572–2579
Carrano CS, Rino CL (2016) A theory of scintillation for two-component
power law irregularity spectra: overview and numerical
results. Radio Sci 51(6):789–813
Carrano CS, Groves KM, McNeil WJ, Doherty PH (2013) Direct
measurement of the residual in the ionosphere-free linear combination
during scintillation. In: Proceedings of the ION NTM
2013, Institute of Navigation, San Diego, CA, January 27–29,
pp 585–596
Cicone A (2019) Nonstationary signal decomposition for dummies.
In: Advances in mathematical methods and high performance
computing, Springer, Cham, 2019, pp 69–82
Cicone A (2020) Iterative filtering as a direct method for the decomposition
of nonstationary signals. Numer Algorith 2020:1–17
Cicone A, Dell’Acqua P (2019) Study of boundary conditions in the
iterative filtering method for the decomposition of nonstationary
signals. J Comput Appl Math 2020(373):112248
Cicone A, Zhou H (2020) Iterative filtering algorithm numerical
analysis with new efficient implementations based on FFT. Submitted.
ArXiv: 1802.01359
Cicone A, Liu J, Zhou H (2016) Adaptive local iterative filtering
for signal decomposition and instantaneous frequency analysis.
Appl Comput Harm Anal 41(2):384–411
Conker RS, El-Arini MB, Hegarty CJ, Hsiao T (2003) Modeling
the effects of ionospheric scintillation on GPS/Satellite-Based
Augmentation System availability. Radio Sci 38(1):1–1
De Franceschi G, Spogli L, Alfonsi L, Romano V, Cesaroni C, Hunstad
I (2019) The ionospheric irregularities climatology over
Svalbard from solar cycle 23. Sci Rep 9(1):1–14
Forte B (2005) Optimum detrending of raw GPS data for scintillation
measurements at auroral latitudes. J Atmos Solar Terr Phys
67(12):1100–1109
Forte B, Radicella SM (2002) Problems in data treatment for ionospheric
scintillation measurements. Radio Sci 37(6):1–8
Forte B, Radicella SM (2004) Geometrical control of scintillation
indices: what happens for GPS satellites. Radio Sci 39(5):1–13
Fremouw EJ, Leadabrand RL, Livingston RC, Cousins MD, Rino
CL, Fair BC, Long RA (1978) Early results from the DNA
Wideband satellite experiment—Complex-signal scintillation.
Radio Sci 13(1):167–187
Ghafoori F, Skone S (2015) Impact of equatorial ionospheric irregularities
on GNSS receivers using real and synthetic scintillation
signals. Radio Sci 50(4):294–317
Gherm VE, Zernov NN, Strangeways HJ (2011) Effects of diffraction
by ionospheric electron density irregularities on the range error
in GNSS dual-frequency positioning and phase decorrelation.
Radio Sci 46(3):1–10
Ghobadi H, Testa P, Spogli L, Cafaro M, Alfonsi L, Romano V,
Bru R (2019) User-oriented ICT cloud architecture for highaccuracy
GNSS-based services. Sensors 19(11):2635
Huang NE, Wu Z, Long SR, Arnold KC, Chen X, Blank K (2009)
On instantaneous frequency. Adv Adap Data Anal 1(2):177–229
Keskinen MJ, Ossakow SL (1983) Theories of high-latitude ionospheric
irregularities: a review. Radio Sci 18(6):1077–1091
Lin L, Wang Y, Zhou H (2009) Iterative filtering as an alternative
algorithm for empirical mode decomposition. Adv Adap Data
Anal 1(4):543–560
Linty N, Minetto A, Dovis F, Spogli L (2018) Effects of phase scintillation
on the GNSS positioning error during the September
2017 storm at Svalbard. Space Weather 16(9):1317–1329
Materassi M, Mitchell CN (2007) Wavelet analysis of GPS amplitude
scintillation: a case study. Radio Sci 42(1):1–10
Materassi M, Piersanti M, Consolini G, Diego P, D’Angelo G, Bertello
I, Cicone A (2019) Stepping into the equatorward boundary
of the auroral oval: preliminary results of multi scale statistical
analysis. Ann Geophys 62(4):455
McCaffrey AM, Jayachandran PT (2019) Determination of the refractive
contribution to GPS phase “Scintillation”. J Geophys Res
Space Phys 124(2):1454–1469
Moen J, Oksavik K, Alfonsi L, Daabakk Y, Romano V, Spogli L (2013)
Space weather challenges of the polar cap ionosphere. J Space
Weather Space Clim 2013(3):A02
Muella MT, de Paula ER, Jonah OF (2014) GPS L1-frequency observations
of equatorial scintillations and irregularity zonal velocities.
Surv Geophys 35(2):335–357
Mushini SC, Jayachandran PT, Langley RB, MacDougall JW, Pokhotelov
D (2012) Improved amplitude-and phase-scintillation indices
derived from wavelet detrended high-latitude GPS data. GPS
Sol 16(3):363–373
Najmafshar M, Skone S, Ghafoori F (2014) GNSS data processing
investigations for characterizing ionospheric scintillation. In:
ION GNSS, 2014, Institute of Navigation, Tampa, FL, September
8–12, pp 1190–1202
Niu F, Morton Y, Wang J, Pelgrum W (2012) GPS carrier phase
detrending methods and performances for ionosphere scintillation
studies. In: Proceedings of the ION GNSS, 2012, Institute
of Navigation, Nashville, TN, September 17–21, pp 1462–1467
Park J, Sreeja V, Aquino M, Cesaroni C, Spogli L, Dodson A, De
Franceschi G (2016) Performance of ionospheric maps in support
of long baseline GNSS kinematic positioning at low latitudes.
Radio Sci 51(5):429–442
Piersanti M, Cesaroni C, Spogli L, Alberti T (2017) Does TEC react to
a sudden impulse as a whole? The 2015 Saint Patrick’s Day storm
event. Adv Space Res 60(8):1807–1816
Piersanti M, Materassi M, Cicone A, Spogli L, Zhou H, Ezquer RG
(2018) Adaptive local iterative filtering: a promising technique
for the analysis of nonstationary signals. J Geophys Res Space
Phys 123(1):1031–1046
Rino C (2011) The theory of scintillation with applications in remote
sensing. Wiley, New York
Romano V, Ghobadi H, Spogli L, Cafaro M, Alfonsi L, Cicone A,
Linty N (2019) Disentangling ionospheric refraction and diffraction
effects in GNSS raw phase through fast iterative filtering
technique. In: AGU fall meeting 2019. AGU
Spogli L, Alfonsi L, Cilliers PJ, Correia E, De Franceschi G, Mitchell
CN, Romano V, Kinrade J, Cabrera MA (2013) GPS scintillations
and total electron content climatology in the southern low, middle
and high latitude regions. Ann Geophys 56(2):0220
GPS Solutions (2020) 24:85
Spogli L, Piersanti M, Cesaroni C, Materassi M, Cicone A, Alfonsi L,
Romano V, Ezquer RG (2019) Role of the external drivers in the
occurrence of low-latitude ionospheric scintillation revealed by
multi-scale analysis. J Space Weather Space Clim 2019(9):A35
Stallone A, Cicone A, Materassi M, Zhou H (2020) New insights and
best practices for the successful use of Empirical Mode Decomposition.
Iterative Filtering and derived algorithms, Submitted
Tinin MV (2015) Eliminating diffraction effects during multi-frequency
correction in global navigation satellite systems. J Geodesy
89(5):491–503
Van Dierendonck AJ, Arbesser-Rastburg B (2004) Measuring Ionospheric
scintillation in the equatorial region over Africa, including
measurements from SBAS geostationary satellite signals. In:
Proceedings of the ION GNSS 2004, Institute of Navigation, Long
Beach, CA, September 21–24, pp 316–324
Van Dierendonck AJ, Klobuchar J, Quyen H (1993) Ionospheric Scintillation
monitoring using commercial single frequency C/A code
receivers. In: Proceedings of the ION GPS 1993, Institute of Navigation,
Salt Lake City, UT, September 22–24, pp 1333–1342
Wang Y, Zhang QH, Jayachandran PT, Moen J, Xing ZY, Chadwick R,
Ma YZ, Ruohoniemi JM, Lester M (2018) Experimental evidence
on the dependence of the standard GPS phase scintillation index
on the ionospheric plasma drift around noon sector of the polar
ionosphere. J Geophys Res Space Phys 123(3):2370–2378
Wernik AW, Secan JA, Fremouw EJ (2003) Ionospheric irregularities
and scintillation. Adv Space Res 31(4):971–981
Wu Z, Huang NE (2009) Ensemble empirical mode decomposition:
a noise-assisted data analysis method. Adv Adap Data Anal
1(1):1–41
Yeh KC, Liu CH (1982) Radio wave scintillations in the ionosphere.
Proc IEEE 70(4):324–360
Yen NC, Tung CC, Liu HH (1998) The empirical mode decomposition
and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and nonstationary time
series analysis. Proc R Soc Lond A 454:903–995
Zhang L, Morton Y, van Graas F, Beach T (2010) Characterization
of GNSS signal parameters under ionosphere scintillation conditions
using software-based tracking algorithms. In: IEEE/ION
position, location and navigation symposium, Indian Wells, CA,
pp 264–275
Zhang K, Li X, Xiong C, Meng X, Li X, Yuan Y, Zhang X (2019) The
Influence of Geomagnetic Storm of 7‐8 September 2017 on the
Swarm Precise Orbit Determination. J Geophys Res Space Phys
124(8):6971–6984
Type
article
File(s)![]()
Name
Ghobadi2020_Article_DisentanglingIonosphericRefrac.pdf
Description
Article
Size
2.23 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
The MD5 message-digest algorithm can be used to verify the integrity of the file that you have uploaded. You can calculate its value locally via tools that are generally available in each operative system like md5sum
f6283f64a3924c3567ba82588d01dbb4
