Standardized analysis of juvenile pyroclasts in comparative studies of primary magma fragmentation; 1. Overview and workflow

Juvenile pyroclasts, especially in the ash size range, provide important information on primary fragmentation processes, i.e.,
initial explosive magma fragmentation, and on the state of the magma both prior to and at the point of fragmentation and
quenching. There exists an extensive body of literature focusing on the quantification of juvenile particle morphology (shape),
internal textures, and surface features spanning several decades; however, a standardized method has yet to emerge for comparative
studies. No community-wide consensus currently exists (i) regarding the most representative size fraction(s) to be
examined, (ii) on sample preparation procedures (such as whether to use whole-particle silhouettes or 2D cross-sections),
(iii) on imaging techniques and image acquisition parameters, or (iv) on the optimal morphometric parameters to measure.
Lack of a standardized method precludes robust comparison between different studies and laboratories. We propose here a
preliminary “best practices” and workflow for characterization of juvenile pyroclasts, for comparative studies of primary
fragmentation. If the community follows such a standardized method, it will become possible to accumulate a large volume
of consistent data on juvenile pyroclasts from a range of eruption styles, fragmentation mechanisms, and magma compositions.
This will ultimately allow deeper insights into the full panoply of magma-to-pyroclast processes that drive particleproducing
volcanic eruptions. One or more “fragmentation diagrams” may eventually be developed to allow different types
of magmatic and phreatomagmatic explosive eruptions to be distinguished based on their products.

The Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), using a Discovery Grant to the first author (RGPIN-2015-06782).

Agustín-Flores J, Németh K, Cronin SJ, Lindsay JM, Kereszturi G
(2015) Construction of the North Head (Maungauika) tuff cone:
a product of Surtseyan volcanism, rare in the Auckland Volcanic
Field, New Zealand. Bull Volc 77:article 11
Allen SR, McPhie J (2000) Water-settling and resedimentation of
submarine rhyolitic pumice at Yali, eastern Aegean. Greece J
Volcanol Geotherm Res 95:285–307
Alvarado GE, Mele D, Dellino P, de Moor JM, Avard G (2016) Are the
ashes from the latest eruptions (2010–2016) at Turrialba volcano
(Costa Rica) related to phreatic or phreatomagmatic events? J
Volcanol Geotherm Res 327:407–415
Andronico D, Cristaldi A, Del Carlo P, Taddeucci J (2009) Shifting
styles of basaltic explosive activity during the 2002–03 eruption
of Mt. Etna. Italy J Volcanol Geotherm Res 180:110–122
Andronico D, Taddeucci J, Cristaldi A, Miraglia L, Scarlato P, Gaeta M
(2013) The 15 March 2007 paroxysm of Stromboli: video-image
analysis, and textural and compositional features of the erupted
deposit. Bull Volc 75:733
Andronico D, Di Roberto A, De Beni E, Behncke B, Bertagnini A,
Del Carlo P, Pompilio M (2018) Pyroclastic density currents at
Etna volcano, Italy: The 11 February 2014 case study. J Volcanol
Geotherm Res 357:92–105
Austin-Erickson A, Büttner R, Dellino P, Ort MH, Zimanowski B
(2008) Phreatomagmatic explosions of rhyolitic magma: experimental
and field evidence. J Geophys Res 113:paper B11201
Austin-Erickson A, Ort MH, Carrasco-Núñez G (2011) Rhyolitic
phreatomagmatism explored: Tepexitl tuff ring (Eastern Mexican
Volcanic Belt). J Volcanol Geotherm Res 201:325–341
Avery MR, Panter KS, Gorsevski PV (2017) Distinguishing styles of
explosive eruptions at Erebus, Redoubt and Taupo volcanoes
using multivariate analysis of ash morphometrics. J Volcanol
Geotherm Res 332:1–13
Bagheri GH, Bonadonna C, Manzella I, Vonlanthen P (2015) On the
characterization of size and shape of irregular particles. Powder
Tech 270:141–153
Barberi F, Cioni R, Rosi M, Santacroce R, Sbrana A, Vecci R (1989)
Magmatic and phreatomagmatic phases in explosive eruptions
of Vesuvius as deduced by grain-size and component analysis of
the pyroclastic deposits. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 38:287–307
Barberi F, Bertagnini A, Landi P, Principe C (1992) A review on phreatic
eruptions and their precursors. J Volcanol Geotherm Res
52:231–246
Beget JE, Larsen JF, Neal CA, Nye CJ, Schaefer JR (2005) Preliminary
volcano-hazard assessment for Okmok volcano, Umnak
Island Alaska. In: Alaska Department of Natural Resources,
Division of Geological & Geophysical Surveys, Report of
Investigations 2004–3
Bernard B (2013) Homemade ashmeter: a low-cost, high-efficiency
solution to improve tephra field-data collection for contemporary
explosive eruptions. J Appl Volc 2:article 1
Bernard J, Le Pennec JL (2016) The milling factory: Componentrydependent
fragmentation and fines production in pyroclastic
flows. Geology 44:907–910
Bonadonna C, Cioni R, Costa A, et al. (2016) MeMoVolc report on
classification and dynamics of volcanic explosive eruptions.
Bull Volc 78:article 84
Brand BD, Gravley DM, Clarke AB, Lindsay JM, Bloomberg SH,
Agustin-Flores J, Németh K (2014) A combined field and
numerical approach to understanding dilute pyroclastic density
current dynamics and hazard potential: Auckland Volcanic
Field, New Zealand. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 276:215–232
Buckland HM, Eychenne J, Rust AC, Cashman KV (2018) Relating
the physical properties of volcanic rocks to the characteristics
of ash generated by experimental abrasion. J Volcanol Geotherm
Res 349:335–350
Bursik M, Kuehn S, Pouget S, Wallace K, et al. (2015) Tephra 2014:
summary and consensus document; Appendix I – Checklist
for tephra collection. Downloaded from https:// vhub. org/ resou
rces/ 3860/ suppo rting docs on December 3, 2018
Bustillos J, Romero JE, Troncoso L, Guevara A (2016) Tephra fall
at Tungurahua volcano (Ecuador) - 1999–2014: An example of
tephra accumulation from a long-lasting eruptive cycle. Geofis
Intl 55:55–67
Büttner R, Dellino P, Zimanowski B (1998) Physics of thermohydraulic
explosions. Phys Rev E 57:5726–5729
Büttner R, Dellino P, Zimanowski B (1999) Identifying magmawater
interaction from the surface features of ash particles.
Nature 401:688–690
Büttner R, Dellino P, La Volpe L, Lorenz V, Zimanowski B (2002)
Thermohydraulic explosions in phreatomagmatic eruptions as
evidenced by the comparison between pyroclasts and products
from Molten Fuel Coolant Interaction experiments. J Geophys
Res 107:article 2277
Caracciolo A, Gurioli L, Marianelli P, Bernard J, Harris AJL (2021)
Textural and chemical features of a “soft” plug emitted during
Strombolian explosions: A case study from Stromboli volcano.
Earth Planet Sci Lett 559:116761
Carey S, Sparks RSJ (1986) Quantitative models of the fallout and
dispersal of tephra from volcanic eruption columns. Bull Volc
48:109–125
Cas RAF, Wright JV (1987) Volcanic successions, modern and
ancient. Allen & Unwin, London, p 528
Casalbore D, Romagnoli C, Chiocci F, Frezza V (2010) Morphosedimentary
characteristics of the volcaniclastic apron around
Stromboli volcano (Italy). Marine Geol 269:132–148
Cashman KV, Scheu B (2015) Magmatic fragmentation. In: Sigurdsson
H, Houghton B, McNutt SR, Rymer H, Stix J (eds)
Encyclopedia of Volcanoes, 2nd edn. Academic Press, London,
pp 459–471
Cashman K, Rust A (2016) Volcanic ash: Generation and spatial variations.
In: Mackie S, Cashman K, Ricketts H, Rust A, Watson M
(eds) Volcanic Ash. Elsevier, pp 5–22
Chamberlain KJ, Barclay J, Preece K, Brown RJ, Davidson JP (2016)
Origin and evolution of silicic magmas at ocean islands: Perspectives
from a zoned fall deposit on Ascension Island, South
Atlantic. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 327:349–360
Cioni R, Sbrana A, Vecci R (1992) Morphologic features of juvenile
pyroclasts from magmatic and phreatomagmatic deposits of
Vesuvius. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 51:61–78
Cioni R, Sulpizio R, Garruccio N (2003) Variability of the eruption
dynamics during a Subplinian event: the Greenish Pumice
eruption of Somma-Vesuvius (Italy). J Volcanol Geotherm Res
124:89–114
Cioni R, Bertagnini A, Santacroce R, Andronico D (2008a) Explosive
activity and eruption scenarios at Somma-Vesuvius (Italy):
Towards a new classification scheme. J Volcanol Geotherm Res
178:331–346
Cioni R, D’Oriano C, Bertagnini A (2008b) Fingerprinting ash deposits
of small scale eruptions by their physical and textural features. J
Volcanol Geotherm Res 177:277–287
Cioni R, Pistolesi M, Bertagnini A, Bonadonna C, Hoskuldsson A,
Scateni B (2014) Insights into the dynamics and evolution of
the 2010 Eyjafjallajökull summit eruption (Iceland) provided by
volcanic ash textures. Earth Planet Sci Lett 394:111–123
Colo’ L, Ripepe M, Gurioli L, Harris AJL (2020) Fragmentation processes
during strombolian explosions revealed using particle size
distribution mapping. Front Earth Sci 8:356
Comida PP, Ross P-S, Zimanowski B, Büttner R (2017) Artificial juvenile
pyroclasts from wet and dry “eruptions”: impact of magma
composition on grain sizes and particle shapes. IAVCEI 2017,
Portland, Oregon, USA
Comida PP, Ross P-S, Lefebvre N, Zimanowski B, Büttner R (2018)
Phreatomagmatic versus magmatic fragmentation: Insights from
juvenile particle analysis. Cities on Volcanoes 10, Naples, Italy
Comida PP, Ross P-S, Dürig T, White JDL, Lefebvre N (2021) Standardized
analysis of juvenile pyroclasts in comparative studies
of primary magma fragmentation; 2. Choice of size fractions
and method optimization. Bull Volc. https:// doi. org/ 10. 1007/
s00445- 021- 01517-5
Colucci S, Palladino DM, Mulukutla GK, Proussevitch AA (2013) 3-D
reconstruction of ash vesicularity: Insights into the origin of ashrich
explosive eruptions. J Volcanol Geotherm Res 255:98–107
Dellino P, La Volpe L (1995) Fragmentation versus transportation
mechanisms in the pyroclastic sequence of Monte Pilato-Rocche
Rosse (Lipari, Italy). J Volcanol Geotherm Res 64:211–231
Dellino P, La Volpe L (1996) Image processing analysis in reconstructing
fragmentation and transportation mechanisms of pyroclastic
deposits. The case of Monte Pilato-Rocche Rosse eruptions,
Lipari (Aeolian islands, Italy). J Volcanol Geotherm Res
71:13–29
Dellino P, Isaia R, La Volpe L, Orsi G (2001) Statistical analysis of
textural data from complex pyroclastic sequences: implications
for fragmentation processes of the Agnano-Monte Spina Tephra
(4.1 ka), Phlegraean Fields, southern Italy. Bull Volc 63:443–461
Dellino P, Gudmundsson MT, Larsen G, Mele D, Stevenson JA, Thordarson
T, Zimanowski B (2012) Ash from the Eyjafjallajökull
eruption (Iceland): Fragmentation processes and aerodynamic
behavior. J Geophys Res Solid Earth 117:B00C04
Devine JD, Gardner JE, Brack HP, Layne GD, Rutherford MJ (1995)
Comparison of microanalytical methods for estimating H2O
contents
of silicic volcanic glasses. Am Mineral 80:319–328
Dioguardi F, Mele D, Dellino P, Dürig T (2017) The terminal velocity
of volcanic particles with shape obtained from 3D X-ray microtomography.
J Volcanol Geotherm Res 329:41–53
D’Oriano C, Bertagnini A, Pompilio M (2011) Ash erupted during
normal activity at Stromboli (Aeolian Islands, Italy) raises questions
on how the feeding system works. Bull Volc 73:471–477
D'Oriano C, Bertagnini A, Cioni R, Pompilio M (2014) Identifying
recycled ash in basaltic eruptions. Sci Rep 4:article 5851
Doubik P, Hill BE (1999) Magmatic and hydromagmatic conduit development
during the 1975 Tolbachik Eruption, Kamchatka, with
implications for hazards assessment at Yucca Mountain, NV. J
Volcanol Geotherm Res 91:43–64
Dürig T, Zimanowski B (2012) “Breaking news” on the formation of
volcanic ash: Fracture dynamics in silicate glass. Earth Planet
Sci Lett 335:1–8
Dürig T, Bowman HM (2021) lsschmidt/PARTISAN (Version 2.0,
March 10, 2021), https:// github. com/ lssch midt/ PARTI SAN/ tree/
v2.0, https:// doi. org/ 10. 5281/ zenodo. 45938 33
Dürig T, Sonder I, Zimanowski B, Beyrichen H, Büttner R (2012a)
Generation of volcanic ash by basaltic volcanism. J Geophys
Res 117:B01204
Dürig T, Mele D, Dellino P, Zimanowski B (2012b) Comparative analyses
of glass fragments from brittle fracture experiments and
volcanic ash particles. Bull Volc 74:691–704
Dürig T, Bowman MH, White JDL, Murch A, Mele D, Verolino A,
Dellino P (2019) PARTIcle Shape ANalyzer PARTISAN – an
open source tool for multi-standard two-dimensional particle
morphometry analysis. Annals of Geophysics 61: AC31, https://
doi. org/ 10. 4401/ ag- 7865
Dürig T, Schmidt LS, White JDL, Bowman MH (2020a) DendroScan:
an open source tool to conduct comparative statistical tests and
dendrogrammatic analyses on particle morphometry. Sci Rep
10:article 21682
Dürig T, White JDL, Murch AP, Zimanowski B, Büttner R, Mele D,
Dellino P, Carey RJ, Schmidt LS, Spitznagel N (2020b) Deep-sea
eruptions boosted by induced fuel–coolant explosions. Nature
Geosci 13:498–503
Dürig T, White JDL, Zimanowski B, Büttner R, Murch A, Carey RJ
(2020c) Deep-sea fragmentation style of Havre revealed by
dendrogrammatic analyses of particle morphometry. Bull Volc
82:article 67
Dürig T, Ross P-S, Dellino P, White JDL, Mele D, Comida PP (2021)
A review of statistical tools for morphometric analysis of juvenile
pyroclasts. Bull Volc 83:article 79
Engwell S, Eychenne J (2016) Contribution of fine ash to the atmosphere
from plumes associated with pyroclastic density currents.
In: Cashman K, Ricketts H, Rust A, Watson M (eds) Shona M.
Volcanic Ash, Elsevier, pp 67–85
Eychenne J, Le Pennec J-L (2012) Sigmoidal particle density distribution
in a subplinian scoria fall deposit. Bull Volc 74:2243–2249
Eychenne J, Le Pennec J-L, Troncoso L, Gouhier M, Nedelec J-M
(2012) Causes and consequences of bimodal grain-size distribution
of tephra fall deposited during the August 2006 Tungurahua
eruption (Ecuador). Bull Volc 74:187–205
Eychenne J, Houghton BF, Swanson DA, Carey RJ, Swavely L (2015)
Dynamics of an open basaltic magma system: The 2008 activity
of the Halema‘uma‘u Overlook vent, Kīlauea Caldera. Earth
Planet Sci Lett 409:49–60
Freret-Lorgeril V, Donnadieu F, Eychenne J, Soriaux C, Latchimy T
(2019) In situ terminal settling velocity measurements at Stromboli
volcano: Input from physical characterization of ash. J Volcanol
Geotherm Res 374:62–79
Fisher RV, Schmincke H-U (1984) Pyroclastic Rocks. Springer-Verlag,
Berlin, p 472
Fitch EP, Fagents SA (2020) Characteristics of rootless tephra
emplaced by high-energy lava–water explosions. Bull Volc
82:article 62
Fitch EP, Fagents SA, Thordarson T, Hamilton CW (2017) Fragmentation
mechanisms associated with explosive lava–water interactions
in a lacustrine environment. Bull Volc 79:12
Gaunt HE, Bernard B, Hidalgo S, Proaño A, Wright H, Mothes P,
Criollo E, Kueppers U (2016) Juvenile magma recognition and
eruptive dynamics inferred from the analysis of ash time series:
The 2015 reawakening of Cotopaxi volcano. J Volcanol Geotherm
Res 328:134–146