Improvements and validation of the IRI UP method under moderate, strong, and severe geomagnetic storms

This work describes several important improvements made to the International Reference Ionosphere UPdate (IRIUP) method, and a careful validation of its performances under disturbed conditions. The IRI UP method has been improved developing an algorithm capable to properly filter wrongly autoscaled ionosonde data to be assimilated, avoiding the use of these in the assimilation process. Furthermore, the preliminary quality check used to choose the variogram model in the Universal Kriging method has been replaced with a new quality check routine (NQCR), based on statistical tests carried out using the variables Q 1 , Q 2 , and cR, built on variogram’s residuals. NQCR objectively identifies the best variogram model from which to get more reliable effective indices maps to be ingested in the IRI model to obtain updated foF2 and hmF2 maps. IRI UP has been applied on 30 different time intervals, between January 1, 2004, and December 31, 2016, characterized by moderate, strong, and severe geomagnetic conditions, over the European region. A statistical comparison between IRI UP and IRI at the truth sites located at Fairford (51.7°N, 1.5°W,
UK) and San Vito (40.6°N, 17.8°E, Italy), for foF2 and hmF2, has been performed. From the statistical validation clearly emerges how IRI UP, for foF2, performs significantly better than IRI, for each of the 30 geomagnetic storms considered. Regarding hmF2, IRI UP performances are lower than those for foF2, although still better than IRI ones. In the light of the results achieved in this investigation, the IRI UP method represents an interesting approach to Space Weather forecast in the ionospheric domain.

Angling MJ, Khattatov B (2006) Comparative study of two assimila-
tive models of the ionosphere. Radio Sci 41:RS5S20. https ://doi.
org/10.1029/2005R S0033 72
Bibl K, Reinisch BW (1978) The universal digital ionosonde. Radio Sci
13:519–530. https ://doi.org/10.1029/RS013 i003p 00519
Bilitza D, Reinisch BW (2008) International reference ionosphere 2007:
improvements and new parameters. Adv Space Res 42(4):599–609.
https ://doi.org/10.1016/j.asr.2007.07.048
Bilitza D, Sheikh M, Eyfrig R (1979) A global model for the height of the
F2-peak using M3000 values from the CCIR numerical map. Telecommun
J 46:549–553
Bilitza D, McKinnell LA, Reinisch B, Fuller-Rowell T (2011) The International
Reference Ionosphere today and in the future. J Geod 85:909–920. https
://doi.org/10.1007/s0019 0-010-0427-x
Bilitza D, Altadill D, Zhang Y, Mertens C, Truhlik V, Richards P, McKinnell LA,
Reinisch B (2014) The International Reference Ionosphere 2012—a model
of international collaboration. J Space Weather Space Clim 4:A07. https ://
doi.org/10.1051/swsc/20140 04
Bilitza D, Altadill D, Truhlik V, Shubin V, Galkin I, Reinisch B, Huang X (2017)
International Reference Ionosphere 2016: from ionospheric climate to
real-time weather predictions. Space Weather 15:418–429. https ://doi.
org/10.1002/2016S W0015 93
Buonsanto MJ (1999) Ionospheric storms—a review. Space Sci Rev 88:563–601
Decker DT, McNamara LF (2007) Validation of ionospheric weather predicted
by global assimilation of ionospheric measurements (GAIM) models.
Radio Sci 42:RS4017. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2007R S0036 32
Galkin IA, Reinisch BW (2008) The new ARTIST 5 for all digisondes. In: Iono-
sonde Network Advisory Group Bulletin, in: IPS Radio and Space Services,
Surry Hills, NSW, Australia, vol 69, pp 1–8. http://www.ips.gov.au/IPSHo
sted/INAG/web-69/2008/artis t5-inag.pdf
Galkin IA, Reinisch BW, Huang X, Bilitza D (2012) Assimilation of GIRO data into
a real-time IRI. Radio Sci 47:7. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2011R S0049 52
Houminer Z, Bennett JA, Dyson PL (1993) Real-time ionospheric model updat-
ing. J Electr Electr Eng Aust 13(2):99–104
Khmyrov GM, Galkin IA, Kozlov AV et al (2008) Exploring digisonde iono-
gram data with SAO-X and DIDBase. In: Proceedings of AIP conference
radio sounding and plasma physics, vol 974, pp 175–185. https ://doi.
org/10.1063/1.28850 27Kitanidis PK (1997) Introduction to geostatistics: application to hydrogeology.
Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kouris SS, Fotiadis DN (2002) Ionospheric variability: a comparative statisti-
cal study. Adv Space Res 29(6):977–985. https ://doi.org/10.1016/S0273
-1177(02)00045 -5
Kouris SS, Fotiadis DN, Xenos TD (1998) On the day-to-day variation of foF2
and M(3000)F2. Adv Space Res 22(6):873–876. https ://doi.org/10.1016/
S0273 -1177(98)00116 -1
Liu RY, Smith PA, King JW (1983) A new solar index which leads to improved
foF2 predictions using the CCIR Atlas. Telecommun J 50:408–414
McNamara LF, Decker DT, Welsh JA, Cole DG (2007) Validation of the Utah
State University global assimilation of ionospheric measurements (GAIM)
model predictions of the maximum usable frequency for a 3000 km
circuit. Radio Sci 42:RS3015. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2006R S0035 89
McNamara LF, Baker CR, Decker DT (2008) Accuracy of USU-GAIM specifica-
tions of foF2 and M(3000)F2 for a worldwide distribution of ionosonde
locations. Radio Sci 43:RS1011. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2007R S0037 54
McNamara LF, Retterer JM, Baker CR, Bishop GJ, Cooke DL, Roth CJ, Welsh JA
(2010) Longitudinal structure in the CHAMP electron densities and their
implications for global ionospheric modeling. Radio Sci 45:RS2001. https
://doi.org/10.1029/2009R S0042 51
McNamara LF, Bishop GJ, Welsh JA (2011) Assimilation of ionosonde profiles
into a global ionospheric model. Radio Sci 46:RS2006. https ://doi.
org/10.1029/2010R S0044 57
Menvielle M, Berthelier A (1991) The K-derived planetary indices: description
and availability. Rev Geophys 29(3):415–432
Nava B, Radicella SM, Azpilicueta F (2011) Data ingestion into NeQuick 2. Radio
Sci 46(6):RS0D17. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2010R S0046 35
Pezzopane M, Scotto C (2005) The INGV software for the automatic scaling of
foF2 and MUF(3000)F2 from ionograms: a performance comparison with
ARTIST 4.01 from Rome data. J Atmos Sol Terr Phys 67(12):1063–1073.
https ://doi.org/10.1016/j.jastp .2005.02.022
Pezzopane M, Scotto C (2007) The automatic scaling of critical frequency foF2
and MUF(3000)F2: a comparison between Autoscala and ARTIST 4.5 on
Rome data. Radio Sci 42:RS4003. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2006R S0035 81
Pezzopane M, Scotto C, Tomasik Ł, Krasheninnikov I (2009) Autoscala: an
aid for different ionosondes. Acta Geophys 58(3):513–526. https ://doi.
org/10.2478/s1160 0-009-0038-1
Pezzopane M, Pietrella M, Pignatelli A, Zolesi B, Cander LR (2011) Assimilation
of autoscaled data and regional and local ionospheric models as input
sources for real-time 3-D International Reference Ionosphere modeling.
Radio Sci 46:RS5009. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2011R S0046 97
Pezzopane M, Pietrella M, Pignatelli A, Zolesi B, Cander LR (2013) Testing the
three-dimensional IRI-SIRMUP-P mapping of the ionosphere for disturbed
periods. Adv Space Res 52(10):1726–1736. https ://doi.org/10.1016/j.
asr.2012.11.028
Pietrella M (2015) A software package generating long term and near real
time predictions of the critical frequencies of the F2 layer over Europe
and its applications. Int J Geosci 6(4):373–387. https ://doi.org/10.4236/
ijg.2015.64029
Pignalberi A, Pezzopane M, Tozzi R, De Michelis P, Coco I (2016) Comparison
between IRI and preliminary swarm langmuir probe measurements dur-
ing the St. Patrick storm period. Earth Planets Space 68(1):93. https ://doi.
org/10.1186/s4062 3-016-0466-5
Pignalberi A, Pezzopane M, Rizzi R, Galkin IA (2018a) Effective solar indices for
ionospheric modeling: a review and a proposal for a real-time regional IRI.
Surv Geophys 39:125–167. https ://doi.org/10.1007/s1071 2-017-9438-yPignalberi A, Pezzopane M, Rizzi R, Galkin IA (2018b) Correction to: Effective
solar indices for ionospheric modeling: a review and a proposal for a real-
time regional IRI. Surv Geophys 39:169. https ://doi.org/10.1007/s1071
2-017-9453-z
Reinisch BW, Galkin IA (2011) Global ionospheric radio observatory
(GIRO). Earth Planets Space 63(4):377–381. https ://doi.org/10.5047/
eps.2011.03.001
Reinisch BW, Huang X (1983) Automatic calculation of electron density profiles
from digital ionograms: 3. Processing of bottom side ionograms. Radio
Sci 18(3):477–492. https ://doi.org/10.1029/RS018 i003p 00477
Reinisch BW, Huang X, Galkin IA, Paznukhov V, Kozlov A (2005) Recent
advances in real-time analysis of ionograms and ionospheric drift meas-
urements with digisondes. J Atmos Sol Terr Phys 67(12):1054–1062. https
://doi.org/10.1016/j.jastp .2005.01.009
Rostoker G (1972) Geomagnetic indices. Rev Geophys Space Phys 10:157
Scotto C (2009) Electron density profile calculation technique for Autoscala
ionogram analysis. Adv Space Res 44:756–766. https ://doi.org/10.1016/j.
asr.2009.04.037
Scotto C, Pezzopane M (2002) A software for automatic scaling of foF2 and
MUF(3000)F2 from ionograms. In: Proceedings of the XXVII general
assembly of the international union of radio science, 17–24 August,
Maastricht, The Netherlands. International Union of Radio Science, CD-
ROM, Ghent
Scotto C, Pezzopane M (2008) Removing multiple reflections from the F2 layer
to improve Autoscala performance. J Atmos Sol Terr Phys 70(15):1929–
1934. https ://doi.org/10.1016/j.jastp .2008.05.012
Scotto C, Pezzopane M, Zolesi B (2012) Estimating the vertical electron
density profile from an ionogram: on the passage from true to virtual
heights via the target function method. Radio Sci 47:RS1007. https ://doi.
org/10.1029/2011R S0048 33
Shim JS, Kuznetsova M, Rastatter L et al (2011) CEDAR electrodynamics
thermosphere ionosphere (ETI) challenge for systematic assessment
of ionosphere/thermosphere models: nmF2, hmF2, and vertical drift
using ground-based observations. Space Weather 9:S12003. https ://doi.
org/10.1029/2011S W0007 27
Thompson DC, Scherliess L, Sojka JJ, Schunk RW (2006) The Utah State Univer-
sity Gauss–Markov Kalman filter of the ionosphere: the effect of slant TEC
and electron density profile data on model fidelity. J Atmos Sol Terr Phys
68(9):947–958. https ://doi.org/10.1016/j.jastp .2005.10.011
Tsagouri I, Zolesi B, Belehaki A, Cander LR (2005) Evaluation of the perfor-
mance of the real-time updated simplified ionospheric regional model
for the European area. J Atmos Sol-Terr Phys 67(12):1137–1146. https ://
doi.org/10.1016/j.jastp .2005.01.012
Zolesi B, Cander LR (2014) Ionospheric prediction and forecasting. Springer,
Berlin
Zolesi B, Belehaki A, Tsagouri I, Cander LR (2004) Real-time updating of the
simplified ionospheric regional model for operational applications. Radio
Sci 39:RS2011. https ://doi.org/10.1029/2003R S0029 36
Zuccheretti E, Tutone G, Sciacca U, Bianchi C, Arokiasamy BJ (2003) The new
AIS-INGV digital ionosonde. Ann Geophys 46(4):647–659. https ://doi.
org/10.4401/ag-4377