Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/2122/1724
AuthorsVogt, J. 
TitleThe weight of pseudo-objectivity
Issue DateOct-1996
Series/Report no.39/5
URIhttp://hdl.handle.net/2122/1724
KeywordsHistorical seismology
pseudo-objectivity
Subject Classification04. Solid Earth::04.06. Seismology::04.06.99. General or miscellaneous 
AbstractFor nearly twenty years, numerous methodological problems of historical seismology, sometimes set in a wider frame, have been discussed by a continuous sequence of papers. One or another paper emphasized the role of pscudo-objectivity without, however, pronouncing these ominous words. Ultimately the need was I'clt to deal with the weight of pseudo-objectivity jn a sll.aightforward way, although scientists, as one enlightened reviewer of this paper wrote, often do not dare to rajse problems of a more or less psychological and episte- mological kind. Besides generaI statements, a random set of surprising examples is given, from the author's own experience or tì.om his readings. The major problem of computerized catalogues is emphasized. Even modern macroseismic enquiries, sometimes considered a routine work, don't escape the pitfalls of pseudo-ob-jectivity. While subjectivity is despised, with sometimes extreme statements, condemning historical seismology on the whole, a kind of "constructive subjectivity" with an ability to master complex problems, seem, preferable to the dangers of a growing pseudo-objectivity.
Appears in Collections:Annals of Geophysics

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
09 vogt.pdf2.47 MBAdobe PDFView/Open
Show full item record

Page view(s)

74
checked on Apr 23, 2017

Download(s)

181
checked on Apr 23, 2017

Google ScholarTM

Check